Faculty Bibliography

Treatment 2.0 is an initiative launched by UNAIDS and WHO in 2011 to catalyze the next phase of treatment scale-up for HIV. The initiative defines strategic activities in 5 key areas, drugs, diagnostics, commodity costs, service delivery and community engagement in an effort to simplify treatment, expand access and maximize program efficiency. For adults, many of these activities have already been turned into treatment policies. The recent WHO recommendation to use a universal first line regimen regardless of gender, pregnancy and TB status is a treatment simplification very much in line with Treatment 2.0. But despite that fact that Treatment 2.0 encompasses all people living with HIV, we have not seen the same evolution in policy development for children. In this paper we discuss how Treatment 2.0 principles can be adapted for the pediatric population. There are several intrinsic challenges. The need for distinct treatment regimens in children of different ages makes it hard to define a one size fits all approach. In addition, the fact that many providers are reluctant to treat children without the advice of specialists can hamper decentralization of service delivery. But at the same time, there are opportunities that can be availed now and in the future to scale up pediatric treatment along the lines of Treatment 2.0. We examine each of the five pillars of Treatment 2.0 from a pediatric perspective and present eight specific action points that would result in simplification of pediatric treatment and scale up of HIV services for children.

BACKGROUND: A key advantage of monitoring HIV viral load (VL) in persons receiving antiretroviral therapy (ART) is the ability to detect virologic failure before clinical deterioration or resistance occurs. Detection of virologic failure will help clarify the need for enhanced adherence counseling or a change to second- line therapy. Low-cost, locally performable alternates to expensive VL assays are needed where resources are limited. METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: We monitored the response to 48-week ART in 100 treatment-naive Kenyan adults using a low-cost VL measurement, the Cavidi reverse transcriptase (RT) assay and gold-standard assays, Roche RNA PCR and Bayer Versant HIV-1 RNA (bDNA) assays. In Altman-Bland plots, the mean difference in viral loads between the three assays was small (<0.5 log(10) copies/mL). However, the limits of agreement between the methods exceeded the biologically relevant change of 0.5 log copies/ml. Therefore, the RT assay cannot be used interchangeably with the other assays to monitor individual patients. The RT assay was 100% sensitive in detecting viral loads of > or =400 copies/ml compared to gold-standard assays. After 24 weeks of treatment, viral load measured by the RT assay was undetectable in 95% of 65 patients with undetectable RNA PCR VL (<400 copies/ml), 90% of 67 patients with undetectable bDNA VL, and 96% of 57 patients with undetectable VL in both RNA PCR and bDNA assays. The negative predictive value of the RT assay was 100% compared to either assay; the positive predictive value was 86% compared to RNA PCR and 70% compared to bDNA. CONCLUSION: The RT assay compared well with gold standard assays. Our study highlights the importance of not interchanging viral load assays when monitoring an individual patient. Furthermore, the RT assay may be limited by low positive predictive values when used in populations with low prevalence of virologic failure

PURPOSE OF REVIEW: We review the current literature supporting adoption of higher CD4 thresholds for initiation of antiretroviral treatment and survey progress in adoption of early treatment policies in resource-limited settings. We highlight some of the challenges and opportunities implementation of early treatment will bring. RECENT FINDINGS: The initial success of combination antiretroviral treatment resulted in the recommendation to treat early all individuals with HIV. However, the gradual realization that antiretroviral treatment was associated with toxicity led to a more tempered approach. Recent cohort studies and some clinical trials have shown that delaying treatment is associated with increased morbidity and mortality. SUMMARY: Early treatment is routinely practiced in developed countries. Now, early treatment is being adopted as a strategy in many resource-limited settings. The implications of this policy shift are not known, but we predict early treatment will have important consequences for the health system, the individual, and the community. Whereas these consequences will bring significant challenges, the increased numbers of HIV-infected individuals on treatment will result in many new opportunities - antiretroviral treatment will become less expensive, systems to deliver chronic care will be strengthened, and the policy shift will focus greater attention on pregnant women and children. Finally, some authors postulate that early treatment may impact HIV transmission

Early diagnosis of pediatric HIV infection is confounded by persistence of maternal antibodies until 18 months, necessitating the use of expensive assays such as HIV-1 DNA PCR, an untenable option in resource-limited settings. This is the first report of a low-cost, commercial, reverse transcriptase (RT) assay for the diagnosis of HIV-1 infection in infants. RT assays were performed on 42 samples from 30 HIV-exposed Kenyan infants under 15 months of age. When correlated with serologic testing conducted after 18 months, the sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values of the RT assay were 92%, 93%, 87% and 96%. A low-cost assay for infant HIV diagnosis is urgently needed, and these results merit further evaluation.

Measurement of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) plasma RNA levels using Roche AMPLICOR version 1.5 (HIV RNA) is an integral part of monitoring HIV-infected patients in industrialized countries. These assays are currently unaffordable in resource-limited settings. We investigated a reverse transcriptase (RT) assay as a less expensive alternative for measuring viral burden that quantifies RT enzyme activity in clinical plasma samples. A comparison of RT and HIV RNA assays was performed on 29 paired plasma samples from patients living in the United States and 21 paired plasma samples from patients living in Cameroon. RT levels correlated significantly with plasma HIV RNA viral loads in plasma from U.S. patients (r = 0.898; P < 0.001) and Cameroonian patients, a majority of whom were infected with HIV-1 clade type CRF02_AG (r = 0.669; P < 0.01). Among 32 samples with HIV viral load of >2,000 copies/ml, 97% had detectable RT activity. One Cameroon sample had undetectable RNA viral load but detectable RT activity of 3 fg/ml. The RT assay is a simple and less expensive alternative to the HIV RNA assay. Field studies comparing these assays in resource-limited settings are warranted to assess the practicality and usefulness of this assay for monitoring HIV-infected patients on antiretroviral therapy

BACKGROUND: CD8 cell responses to human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) have been correlated with virus control in adults, and this study outcome has been controversial. Attempts to establish the same correlation in small numbers of children have also been made, with similar controversy resulting. METHODS: A total of 110 perinatally infected children were studied. Nine of the children (mean age, 1.9 years vs. 11.8 years for the remaining 101 children) received treatment with antiretrovirals within the first 3 months of life. CD4 cell and HIV RNA levels were measured. Production of interferon- gamma after exposure to recombinant vaccinia vectors was measured by enzyme-linked immunospot (ELISPOT) assay. RESULTS: Responses to Pol and Gag antigens exceeded those to Nef and Env antigens, with responses significantly approximated by a quadratic function for which peak responses occurred at plasma HIV RNA levels of 103-104 HIV RNA copies/mL. Children who are treated early in life with highly active antiretroviral therapy have fewer total responses of ELISPOT-forming cells to HIV antigens than do children who are treated later in life

The effect of highly active antiretroviral therapy (HAART) in 85 children infected with human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) was compared retrospectively among Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) immunologic groups 1-3. The duration of HAART did not vary significantly among the immunologic groups (median, 39.07 months). The CD4 cell percentage increased in 39.1%, 58.3%, and 90% of patients in CDC groups 1-3, respectively (P <.001). HAART resulted in the suppression of HIV-1 below detectable levels in 34.8%, 25%, and 32% of patients in the 3 CDC groups, respectively, and in a frequent switch from syncytium-inducing to nonsyncytium-inducing virus. Thymic excision circles increased in a subset of patients with increases in CD4 cell percentage independently of HIV RNA level. The results support the option of delaying HAART in early asymptomatic HIV-1 disease in children and the use of other markers of disease progression, in addition to virus load

In individuals infected with human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), specific immunity is associated with a more diverse viral repertoire and slower disease progression. Attempts to enhance antiviral immunity with therapeutic vaccination have shown that recombinant glycoprotein (RGP) vaccines are safe, well tolerated, and immunogenic, but the effect of RGP vaccines on the viral repertoire is unknown. We evaluated diversification of the viral envelope in 12 HIV-infected children who received placebo or RGP vaccines. At baseline, 11 of 12 patients had multiple viral variants. On follow-up 6 months later, children who had a strong vaccine-associated lymphoproliferative immune response showed less viral diversification than those in whom the immune response was weak or absent. These results suggest that the immune response elicited by RGP vaccines does not exert a significant selection pressure on the viral quasispecies and therefore may not be helpful in changing the course of the disease

The evolution of HIV-1 quasispecies in patients during the first year of life was investigated in 10 vertically infected infants, using heteroduplex analysis of the V3-V5 region of env. Four subjects, who showed little viral evolution during the period of the study, had rapid progression of disease and early loss of CD4(+) cells. The remaining six subjects, who were slow progressors, evolved new viral variants within 6 months, and in one case by 1 month of age. Of the four patients who were PCR positive at birth, one was infected with multiple HIV-1 variants. These results show that in HIV-infected children, multiple variants may initiate infection and early quasispecies diversification is associated with a favorable clinical outcome