Faculty Bibliography

BACKGROUND: The implications of allograft skin and mucosal biopsy findings on classification of rejection and treatment remain unclear. METHODS: Following facial allotransplantation, scheduled surveillance allograft skin and mucosal biopsy specimens were obtained. Clinical concern for acute rejection prompted biopsies off schedule. Compilation of biopsy results, Banff grading, immunosuppression, and clinical correlation were critically reviewed for a 2-year follow-up. RESULTS: A total of 39 biopsy specimens at 21 time points were obtained for analysis, including allograft skin (n = 21), mucosa (n = 17), and a lesion (n = 1). The patient had three episodes of acute rejection warranting treatment. Discordance between skin and mucosa occurred in 55.6 percent of biopsy specimens (p = 0.01). Mucosa concordance with the clinical evaluation occurred in 38.9 percent of biopsy specimens (p = 0.02), and skin concordance with clinical evaluation was present in 81 percent of biopsy specimens (p = 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: The clinical utility of mucosal biopsy remains elusive. The authors' experience suggests that mucosal or skin biopsy, alone, should not drive the decision-making process in treatment. Skin biopsies are more likely to confirm clinical suspicion of rejection than mucosal histology. Data from other institutions are lacking, and future reporting may help elucidate the role of mucosal and skin biopsy in facial allotransplantation. CLINICAL QUESTIONS/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Diagnostic, V.

INTRODUCTION: The anatomy of the facial artery, its tortuosity, and branch patterns are well documented. To date, a reliable method of identifying the facial artery, based on surface landmarks, has not been described. The purpose of this study is to characterize the relationship of the facial artery with several facial topographic landmarks, and to identify a location where the facial artery could predictably be identified. METHODS: Following institutional review board approval, 20 hemifacial dissections on 10 cadaveric heads were performed. Distances from the facial artery to the oral commissure, mandibular angle, lateral canthus, and Manson's point were measured. Distances were measured and confirmed clinically using Doppler examination in 20 hemifaces of 10 healthy volunteers. RESULTS: Manson's point identifies the facial artery with 100% accuracy and precision, within a 3 mm radius in both cadaveric specimens and living human subjects. Cadaveric measurements demonstrated that the facial artery is located 19 mm +/- 5.5 from the oral commissure, 31 mm +/- 6.8 from the mandibular angle, 92 mm +/- 8.0 from the lateral canthus. Doppler examination on healthy volunteers (5 male, 5 female) demonstrated measurements of 18 mm +/- 4.0, 50 mm +/- 6.4, and 79 mm +/- 8.2, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: The identification of the facial artery is critical for the craniofacial surgeon in order to avoid inadvertent injury, plan for local flaps, and in preparation of a recipient vessel for free tissue microvascular reconstruction. Manson's point can aid the surgeon in consistently indentifying the facial artery.

BACKGROUND: The purposes of this study were to report a 7-year experience of microvascular reconstruction of scalp defects, compare flap type and outcomes, and evaluate the implications of short and long term complications. METHODS: Following institutional review board approval, a single surgeon's patients requiring microvascular scalp reconstruction were retrospectively reviewed from 2005 to 2011. Flap choice, complications, and outcomes were statistically analyzed. RESULTS: Nineteen patients met inclusion criteria (10 male and 9 female) with a mean age of 60.2 +/- 21.4 years (range, 23-90 years). All free tissue transfers (n = 20) achieved 100% soft tissue coverage. Mean size calvarial defect was 106.6 +/- 67.2 cm (range, 35-285 cm), with 11 requiring cranioplasty. Free flaps included the following: 13 anteriolateral thigh, 5 ulnar, 1 latissimus dorsi, and 1 thoracodorsal artery perforator. Mean flap size was 154.1 +/- 87.3 cm (range, 42-336 cm). Early complications (<30 days following surgery) occurred in 21.1% of patients and late complications (>30 days following surgery) in 52.6% of patients. Patients with an early complication were 2 times more likely to develop a late complication (relative risk, 2.1) but did not reach statistical significance. Late complications were more likely to require surgical intervention, 84.2% versus 60% of early complications (P = 0.079). CONCLUSIONS: Microvascular free tissue transfer is the mainstay of complex scalp defects but carries a high likelihood of future reoperations. Early complications are less concerning than late complications, as the need for future surgical intervention is associated with late complications. There is lack of evidence to support a superior flap choice.

PURPOSE: Abdominal compartment syndrome (ACS) is a severe complication of ventral hernia repair. The aims of this study were to investigate the effects of intra-abdominal pressure on the physiologic changes of abdominal wall reconstruction and component separation in a porcine model. METHODS: Ventral hernia repair (VHR) was simulated by abdominal fascial imbrication of a 10 x 15 cm defect in 45 Yorkshire pigs assigned to five experimental groups. ACS was simulated by a Stryker endoscopy insufflator with intra-abdominal pressure elevated to 20 mmHg in two groups. Component separation was performed in one of these groups and in one group without ACS. Physiological parameters were measured before and after the procedures and monitored for 4 h. The animals were euthanized for histologic analysis of organ damage. RESULTS: VHR led to an increase in intra-abdominal pressure, bladder pressure, and central venous pressure by an average of 14.89, 13.93, and 14.69 mmHg (p < 0.001) in all animals. Component separation was performed in 25 animals and the three pressures reduced by 9.11, 8.00, 7.89 mmHg (p < 0.001). ACS correlated with higher percentages of large and small bowel necrosis compared to groups without abdominal compartment syndrome. CONCLUSIONS: The results confirm that primary repair of large abdominal wall defects leads to increased intra-abdominal pressure, which can be reduced with component separation. In animals with ACS, component separation may reduce the risk of organ damage. Central venous pressure, bladder pressure, and other physiologic parameters accurately correlated with elevated intra-abdominal pressure and may have utility as markers for diagnosis of ACS.

Efficacy of prophylactic antibiotics in craniofacial fracture management is controversial. The purpose of this study was to compare evidence-based literature recommendations regarding antibiotic prophylaxis in facial fracture management with expert-based practice. A systematic review of the literature was performed to identify published studies evaluating pre-, peri-, and postoperative efficacy of antibiotics in facial fracture management by facial third. Study level of evidence was assessed according to the American Society of Plastic Surgery criteria, and graded practice recommendations were made based on these assessments. Expert opinions were garnered during the Advanced Orbital Surgery Symposium in the form of surveys evaluating senior surgeon clinical antibiotic prescribing practices by time point and facial third. A total of 44 studies addressing antibiotic prophylaxis and facial fracture management were identified. Overall, studies were of poor quality, precluding formal quantitative analysis. Studies supported the use of perioperative antibiotics in all facial thirds, and preoperative antibiotics in comminuted mandible fractures. Postoperative antibiotics were not supported in any facial third. Survey respondents (n = 17) cumulatively reported their antibiotic prescribing practices over 286 practice years and 24,012 facial fracture cases. Percentages of prescribers administering pre-, intra-, and postoperative antibiotics, respectively, by facial third were as follows: upper face 47.1, 94.1, 70.6; midface 47.1, 100, 70.6%; and mandible 68.8, 94.1, 64.7%. Preoperative but not postoperative antibiotic use is recommended for comminuted mandible fractures. Frequent use of pre- and postoperative antibiotics in upper and midface fractures is not supported by literature recommendations, but with low-level evidence. Higher level studies may better guide clinical antibiotic prescribing practices.

BACKGROUND: Microvascular reconstruction is the mainstay of treatment in complex scalp defects. The rate of elderly patients requiring scalp reconstruction is increasing, but outcomes in elderly patients are unclear. The purpose of this study was to systematically review the literature pertaining to free tissue transfer for scalp reconstruction in patients older than 65 years to compare outcomes among different free flaps and determine the safety profile of treatment. METHODS: A systematic review of the available literature of patients undergoing microvascular scalp reconstruction was completed. Details for patients 65 years and older were extracted and reviewed for data analysis. RESULTS: A total of 45 articles (112 patients) were included for analysis. Mean age of the patients was 73.3 +/- 6.3 years (men, 69.4 percent; women, 23.4 percent; not reported, 7.2 percent). Mean flap size was 598 cm (range, 81 to 2500 cm). The mean age of patients developing a complication was 72.8 +/- 6.4 years and patients that did not develop a complication was 73.4 +/- 5.5 years (p = 0.684). Overall, periprocedural mortality was 0.9 percent. Flap failures occurred in two cases (1.8 percent). The overall complication rate was 22.3 percent (n = 25). Complications by flap type varied without reaching statistical significance. CONCLUSIONS: Microvascular reconstruction in complex scalp defects is associated with successful outcomes, and chronologic age does not increase mortality or catastrophic flap complications. The most common flaps used to repair scalp defects are anterolateral thigh and latissimus dorsi, but a superior flap type could not be identified.

Specialty-related cost differences for the treatment of nonmelanoma skin cancer (NMSC) have been previously reported but without taking into account confounding factors. Using a previously validated model for NMSC episode of care, episodes were identified in the Medicare Current Beneficiary Survey claims 2005 to 2007. A γ regression with log link model estimated the effect of physician exposure on total episode costs controlling for sociodemographics, health status and comorbidities, treatment and repair procedures, as well as tumor size and location. Treatment-related NMSC episodes (1285) were identified. In the unadjusted model, episodes managed by generalists were associated with 36% lower costs, those by otolaryngologists/plastic surgeons with 82% higher costs, and those by multiple specialists with 111% higher costs, compared to dermatologists. Cost differences were substantially reduced in the adjusted regression analysis; compared to dermatologists, episodes managed by generalists were associated with 20% lower costs (P < 0.0001), whereas otolaryngologists/plastic surgeons and multiple specialists were associated with 20% (P < 0.01) and 11% (P = 0.02) higher costs, respectively. Overall, comparison between unadjusted and adjusted estimates suggests that controlling for severity and treatment modalities explains most of the specialty cost differences. Our estimates could be subject to residual confounding due to selection bias and the limitations to using claims data to characterize an NMSC episode of care. Adjusting for the severity of the disease and other confounders, our study found much smaller specialty-related cost differences for the management of NMSC than previously reported unadjusted estimates.

BACKGROUND: Despite inclusion of periorbital structures in facial transplants, critical assessment of posttransplantation short- and long-term periorbital function has not been reported. The purpose of this article is to report recovery of ocular and periorbital function, with critical appraisal of posttransplant blink in the setting of revision surgery. METHODS: Prospective ocular and periorbital functional assessments were completed at multiple time points in a patient undergoing facial transplantation and subsequent revision operations. Function was evaluated using clinical ocular examinations, visual acuity assessments, photography, and video at various intervals from preoperative baseline to 13.5 months after transplantation. During this period, revision operations involving periorbital structures were performed at 6 and 9 months after transplantation. RESULTS: Before transplantation, volitional blink was 100 percent in both eyes. Involuntary blink was 40 percent in the right eye and 90 percent in the left eye, with occasional full closure. Following face transplantation, voluntary blink was preserved, partial skin sensation was present, and involuntary blink improved to 70 percent in the right eye and 100 percent in the left eye. Following revision surgery, visual acuity and voluntary and involuntary blink were impaired. By 7.5 months after revision, improvement comparable to the pretransplantation assessment was observed. CONCLUSIONS: Adherence to principles of blink preservation is critical in periorbital transplantation. Involuntary blink is essential for preserving vision, and can be improved after transplantation. Revision surgery may temporarily impair advances made with initial allotransplantation. A comprehensive understanding of ocular biomechanics and function is invaluable to the reconstructive surgeon performing facial transplantation involving periorbital structures and posttransplant revision operations. CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Therapeutic, V.

BACKGROUND: Vascularized composite tissue allotransplant recipients are often highly sensitized to human leukocyte antigens because of multiple prior blood transfusions and other reconstructive operations. The use of peripheral blood obtained from dead donors for crossmatching may be insufficient because of life support measures taken for the donor before donation. No study has been published investigating human leukocyte antigen matching practices in this field. METHODS: A survey addressing human leukocyte antigen crossmatching methods was generated and sent to 22 vascularized composite tissue allotransplantation centers with active protocols worldwide. Results were compiled by center and compared using two-tailed t tests. RESULTS: Twenty of 22 centers (91 percent) responded to the survey. Peripheral blood was the most commonly reported donor sample for vascularized composite tissue allotransplant crossmatching [78 percent of centers (n=14)], with only 22 percent (n=4) using lymph nodes. However, 56 percent of the 18 centers (n=10) that had performed vascularized composite tissue allotransplantation reported that they harvested lymph nodes for crossmatching. Of responding individuals, 62.5 percent (10 of 16 individuals) felt that lymph nodes were the best donor sample for crossmatching. CONCLUSIONS: A slight majority of vascularized composite tissue allotransplant centers that have performed clinical transplants have used lymph nodes for human leukocyte antigen matching, and centers appear to be divided on the utility of lymph node harvest. The use of lymph nodes may offer a number of potential benefits. This study highlights the need for institutional review board-approved crossmatching protocols specific to vascularized composite tissue allotransplantation, and the need for global databases for sharing of vascularized composite tissue allotransplantation experiences.

Vascularized bone flaps are the well-known standards of care for reconstruction of segmental mandibular defects ≥ 6 cm. We developed a large animal critical-sized mandibular defect model in which osseous free fibula flaps were used for reconstruction.In this study a total of eight 3-month-old Yorkshire pigs underwent 6 cm full-thickness resection of the left hemimandible. An osseous free fibula flap from the left leg was harvested and contoured to the mandibular defect. Bone placement and plate position was confirmed with fluoroscopy. Animals were followed with serial radiographs and clinical evaluations.Free fibulas were transferred successfully in all eight animals. The average operative time was 346 minutes, and the average flap ischemia time was 86 minutes. The average volume ratio of reconstructed hemimandibles to nonoperated control hemimandibles was 0.72 ± 0.33. The average maximum fracture load was 689 ± 262 N, and the average ratio of biomechanical fracture load for these samples compared with contralateral control hemimandibles was 0.88 ± 0.25.It is concluded that the porcine osseous free fibula flaps can be reliably harvested and viably transferred to critical-sized posterior mandibular defects with acceptable long-term results. The described microsurgical large animal model is acceptable for use in craniomaxillofacial experimentation.