Scapula fractures: interobserver reliability of classification and treatment
Neuhaus, Valentin; Bot, Arjan G J; Guitton, Thierry G; Ring, David C; Abdel-Ghany, Mahmoud I; Abrams, Jeffrey; Abzug, Joshua M; Adolfsson, Lars E; Balfour, George W; Bamberger, H Brent; Barquet, Antonio; Baskies, Michael; Batson, W Arnold; Baxamusa, Taizoon; Bayne, Grant J; Begue, Thierry; Behrman, Michael; Beingessner, Daphne; Biert, Jan; Bishop, Julius; Alves, Mateus Borges Oliveira; Boyer, Martin; Brilej, Drago; Brink, Peter R G; Brunton, Lance M; Buckley, Richard; Cagnone, Juan Carlos; Calfee, Ryan P; Campinhos, Luiz Augusto B; Cassidy, Charles; Catalano, Louis 3rd; Chivers, Karel; Choudhari, Pradeep; Cimerman, Matej; Conflitti, Joseph M; Costanzo, Ralph M; Crist, Brett D; Cross, Brian J; Dantuluri, Phani; Darowish, Michael; de Bedout, Ramon; DeCoster, Thomas; Dennison, David G; DeNoble, Peter H; DeSilva, Gregory; Dienstknecht, Thomas; Duncan, Scott F; Duralde, Xavier A; Durchholz, Holger; Egol, Kenneth; Ekholm, Carl; Elias, Nelson; Erickson, John M; Esparza, J Daniel Espinosa; Fernandes, C H; Fischer, Thomas J; Fischmeister, Martin; Forigua Jaime, E; Getz, Charles L; Gilbert, Richard S; Giordano, Vincenzo; Glaser, David L; Gosens, Taco; Grafe, Michael W; Filho, Jose Eduardo Grandi Ribeiro; Gray, Robert R L; Gulotta, Lawrence V; Gummerson, Nigel William; Hammerberg, Eric Mark; Harvey, Edward; Haverlag, R; Henry, Patrick D G; Hobby, Jonathan L; Hofmeister, Eric P; Hughes, Thomas; Itamura, John; Jebson, Peter; Jenkinson, Richard; Jeray, Kyle; Jones, Christopher M; Jones, Jedediah; Jubel, Axel; Kaar, Scott G; Kabir, K; Kaplan, F Thomas D; Kennedy, Stephen A; Kessler, Michael W; Kimball, Hervey L; Kloen, Peter; Klostermann, Cyrus; Kohut, Georges; Kraan, G A; Kristan, Anze; Loebenberg, Mark I; Malone, Kevin J; Marsh, L; Martineau, Paul A; McAuliffe, John; McGraw, Iain; Mehta, Samir; Merchant, Milind; Metzger, Charles; Meylaerts, S A; Miller, Anna N; Wolf, Jennifer Moriatis; Murachovsky, Joel; Murthi, Anand; Nancollas, Michael; Nolan, Betsy M; Omara, Timothy; Omara, Timothy; Ortiz, Jose A; Overbeck, Joachim P; Castillo, Alberto Perez; Pesantez, Rodrigo; Polatsch, Daniel; Porcellini, G; Prayson, Michael; Quell, M; Ragsdell, Matthew M; Reid, James G; Reuver, J M; Richard, Marc J; Richardson, Martin; Rizzo, Marco; Rowinski, Sergio; Rubio, Jorge; Guerrero, Carlos G Sanchez; Satora, Wojciech; Schandelmaier, Peter; Scheer, Johan H; Schmidt, Andrew; Schubkegel, Todd A; Schulte, Leah M; Schumer, Evan D; Sears, Benjamin W; Shafritz, Adam B; Shortt, Nicholas L; Siff, Todd; Silva, Dario Mejia; Smith, Raymond Malcolm; Spruijt, Sander; Stein, Jason A; Pemovska, Emilija Stojkovska; Streubel, Philipp N; Swigart, Carrie; Swiontkowski, Marc; Thomas, George; Tolo, Eric T; Turina, Matthias; Tyllianakis, Minos; van den Bekerom, Michel P J; van der Heide, Huub; van de Sande, M A J; van Eerten, P V; Verbeek, Diederik O F; Hoffmann, David Victoria; Vochteloo, A J H; Wagenmakers, Robert; Wall, Christopher J; Wallensten, Richard; Wascher, Daniel C; Weiss, Lawrence; Wiater, J Michael; Wills, Brian P D; Wint, Jeffrey; Wright, Thomas; Young, Jason P; Zalavras, Charalampos; Zura, Robert D; Zyto, Karol
OBJECTIVES: There is substantial variation in the classification and management of scapula fractures. The first purpose of this study was to analyze the interobserver reliability of the OTA/AO classification and the New International Classification for Scapula Fractures. The second purpose was to assess the proportion of agreement among orthopaedic surgeons on operative or nonoperative treatment. DESIGN: Web-based reliability study. SETTING: Independent orthopaedic surgeons from several countries were invited to classify scapular fractures in an online survey. PARTICIPANTS: One hundred three orthopaedic surgeons evaluated 35 movies of three-dimensional computerized tomography reconstruction of selected scapular fractures, representing a full spectrum of fracture patterns. MAIN OUTCOME MEASUREMENTS: Fleiss kappa (kappa) was used to assess the reliability of agreement between the surgeons. RESULTS: The overall agreement on the OTA/AO classification was moderate for the types (A, B, and C, kappa = 0.54) with a 71% proportion of rater agreement (PA) and for the 9 groups (A1 to C3, kappa = 0.47) with a 57% PA. For the New International Classification, the agreement about the intraarticular extension of the fracture (Fossa (F), kappa = 0.79) was substantial and the agreement about a fractured body (Body (B), kappa = 0.57) or process was moderate (Process (P), kappa = 0.53); however, PAs were more than 81%. The agreement on the treatment recommendation was moderate (kappa = 0.57) with a 73% PA. CONCLUSIONS: The New International Classification was more reliable. Body and process fractures generated more disagreement than intraarticular fractures and need further clear definitions.
PMID: 23629469
ISSN: 1531-2291
CID: 991952