Faculty Bibliography

BACKGROUND:The national opioid epidemic has expanded the donor pool for heart transplantation, but concerns remain regarding infectious risk and allograft function. This study compared donor and recipient characteristics, outcomes, and reasons for organ discard between overdose-death donors (ODDs) and donors with all other mechanism of death. METHODS:Data on adult cardiac transplants from 2010 to 2017 were provided by the Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients. Cardiac allografts used in multiple organ transplantations were excluded. Recipient and donor characteristics and organ discard were analyzed with regard to ODDs. Kaplan-Meier curves and log-rank tests described mortality survival. RESULTS:A total of 1,710 of 15,904 (10.8%) cardiac transplantations were from ODDs, approximately a 10-fold increase from 2000 (1.2%). ODDs were more frequently older than 40 years of age (87.2% vs 70.1%; p < 0.001), had higher rates of substance abuse, were more likely hepatitis C positive (1.3% vs 0.2%; p < 0.001), and less frequently required inotropic support at the time of procurement (38.4% vs 44.8%; p < 0.001). Overall survival was not different between the groups (p = 0.066). Discarded ODD allografts were more likely to be hepatitis C positive (30.8% vs 5.3%; p < 0.001) and to be identified as conveying increased risk by the Public Health Services (63.3% vs 13.2%; p < 0.001), but they were less likely to be discarded because of a diseased organ state (28.2% vs 36.1%; p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS:Rates of ODDs have increased corresponding with the worsening opioid epidemic. Even though ODDs have higher rates of hepatitis C, cardiac allograft quality indices are favorable, and recipient outcomes are similar when compared with non-ODDs, a finding indicating that greater use of this donor pool may be appropriate.

Amyloidosis describes a family of related disease states associated with the extracellular tissue deposition of fibrils composed of low-molecular-weight subunits of a variety of proteins circulating as constituents of plasma. Depending on the disease subtype, fibrillar deposits in a several organs including the heart, kidney, liver, and peripheral nerves cause organ dysfunction and associated morbidity and mortality. The most common amyloid fibril deposits associated with cardiac manifestations are of monoclonal light-chain or transthyretin (ATTR) types. This review will focus on the ATTR types of cardiac amyloidosis. ATTR amyloidosis may be associated with abnormal metabolism of wild-type transthyretin (previously called senile systemic amyloidosis) or with hereditary variants in the transthyretin gene. Cardiac amyloidosis is often under-recognized in its early stages, and when a diagnosis of cardiac amyloidosis is made, patients are often at the advanced stages of the disease. Treatments now available appear to exert their benefit predominantly in individuals with the early stages of disease. Increased awareness and early diagnosis of cardiac amyloidosis and continued discovery of effective therapies will increase opportunities to improve clinical outcomes in this patient population.

Purpose: In October 2018, a new US adult heart allocation scheme was enacted in which the etiology of cardiomyopathy can play a significant role in the prioritization of patients listed for transplantation. Given this, we embarked on a review of the diagnoses of patients who underwent therapy for advanced heart failure at our center.
Method(s): We retrospectively reviewed the etiology of cardiomyopathy of patients receiving either durable ventricular assist device (VAD) or orthotopic heart transplantation (OHT) at NYU Langone Medical Center in New York, NY between January 2011 and October 2018. We evaluated for discrepancies between the primary HF diagnosis at time of operation with the ultimate diagnosis, combining both clinical follow-up data and cardiac pathology.
Result(s): During the study period, a total of 110 patients were treated with advanced therapies, of which the majority (74.5%) were male. 40.9% were African American, 35.4% Caucasian, 4.5% Asian, and 23.6% Hispanic. 86.3% underwent VAD and 22.0% underwent OHT. The average age of those undergoing OHT and VAD were 58 and 61 respectively. The most common reported etiology of HF was dilated cardiomyopathy (57.3%), followed by ischemic (36.3%), familial DCM (1.8%), amyloidosis (1.8%), restrictive cardiomyopathy (1.8%), and sarcoidosis (0.9%). On final review of the diagnoses in these patients, 14 (12.7%) had a final diagnosis that was inconsistent with the prior reported one. 5 were clerical errors, but 9 were significant deviations from the prior diagnosis. The most common diagnoses that were misidentified prior to VAD or OHT were cardiac sarcoidosis (2), cardiac amyloidosis (2), and hypertrophic cardiomyopathy (2). Among those 9 patients, 7 patients received VAD with 5 eventually requiring OHT (median days to OHT = 248); 2 patients directly received OHT. All of those are alive except one patient who was lost to follow-up (transferred care to another center). Patients in whom the diagnosis was misidentified prior to VAD or OHT had smaller LV dimensions on transthoracic echocardiography on average than other LVAD or OHT patients with non-ischemic cardiomyopathy.
Conclusion(s): In this single-center review, we found that the majority of HF patients undergoing VAD and OHT had a correct diagnosis for their heart failure prior to treatment, although notably 8.1% had a missed diagnosis at time of intervention (VAD or OHT). Appropriately identifying the subtype of cardiomyopathy remains challenging especially in advanced HF patients but can significantly impact waiting list time in the current organ allocation scheme. A normal or minimally increased LV dimension on echocardiogram in a patient with advanced non-ischemic cardiomyopathy may warrant further workup for another diagnosis.
Copyright

Purpose: The opioid epidemic has expanded the cardiac donor pool, but the concern for primary graft dysfunction (PGD) remains a barrier to wider utilization of these hearts. We analyzed donor characteristics in transplanted and discarded cardiac allografts from overdosed donors (ODD) to determine if viable ODD hearts are being unnecessarily discarded due to inappropriate bias. Method(s): Data on adult cardiac transplantation from 2010-2017 were provided by the SRTR. Eight donor characteristics associated with PGD were analyzed: age, gender, hypertension, high creatinine, cocaine abuse, inotropic support, LVEF, and cardiac arrest. Donor characteristics of transplanted and discarded hearts were compared between ODD and non-ODD. Result(s): ODD comprised 11% (1710/15904) of transplanted hearts and 7% (2600/32678) of discarded hearts. Among transplanted hearts, ODD more frequently were younger than 50 (98% vs 90%), did not have hypertension (86% vs 83%), and did not require inotropic support (62% vs 55%) compared to non-ODD; ODD less frequently were male (63% vs 70%), had no history of cocaine abuse (57% vs 84%), or had creatinine <=1.5 (62% vs 81%). Among discarded hearts, ODD more frequently were younger than 50 (87% vs 46%), had no history of hypertension (78% vs 49%), and did not require inotropic support (51% vs 41%); ODD less often had no history of cocaine abuse (50% vs 86%) or creatinine <=1.5 (61% vs 69%) (Table). Donors known to have at least 6 of 8 favorable qualities comprised 36% (942/2600) of discarded ODD hearts, compared to 28% (9152/32678) of discarded non-ODD hearts (p<0.001). The most common reasons given for discard of ODD hearts with favorable qualities were poor organ function (18%), refusal by all programs (16%), and lack of recipient (11%). Conclusion(s): ODD hearts with favorable qualities are being discarded at disproportionally higher rates than non-ODD hearts. Further studies and better documentation are needed to understand current discard practices and if further expansion into this donor pool is appropriate.