Faculty Bibliography

Gene transfer of p53 induces cell death in most cancer cells, and replication-defective adenoviral vectors expressing p53 are being evaluated in clinical trials. However, low transduction efficiency limits the efficacy of replication-defective vector systems for cancer therapy. The use of replication-competent vectors for gene delivery may have several advantages, holding the potential to multiply and spread the therapeutic agent after infection of only a few cells. However, expression of a transgene may adversely affect viral replication. We have constructed a replicating adenoviral vector (Adp53rc) that expresses high levels of p53 at a late time point in the viral life cycle and also contains a deletion of the adenoviral death protein (ADP). Adp53rc-infected cancer cells demonstrated high levels of p53 expression in parallel with the late expression pattern of the adenoviral fiber protein. p53 expression late in the viral life cycle did not impair effective virus propagation. Survival of several lung cancer cell lines was significantly diminished after infection with Adp53rc, compared with an identical p53-negative control virus. p53 expression also improved virus release and spread. Interestingly, p53 was more cytotoxic than the ADP in cancer cells but less cytotoxic than the ADP in normal cells. In conclusion, late expression of p53 from a replicating virus improves tumor cell killing and viral spread without impairing viral replication. In addition, in combination with a deletion of the ADP, specificity of tumor cell killing is improved.

Strategies to target viral replication to tumor cells hold great promise for the treatment of cancer, but even with replicating adenoviruses complete tumor responses are rarely achieved. To evaluate replicating adenoviral vectors, we have used A549 human lung cancer nude mouse xenografts as a model system. Intratumoral injection of wild-type adenovirus (Ad309) significantly reduced tumor growth from day 14 (p = 0.04) onward; however, tumor volumes reached a plateau at day 50. At 100 days, high levels of titratable virus were present within persistent viable tumors. In contrast to viral injection into established tumors, when tumor cells were infected in vitro with wild-type virus and then mixed with uninfected tumor cells, 1% of infected cells was sufficient to prevent tumor establishment. An E1b-19kD-deleted viral mutant (Ad337) was more efficient than Ad309 in this cell-mixing model. Just 1 cell in 1000 infected with Ad337 prevented tumor growth. However, although better than wild-type virus, Ad337 was unable to eradicate established flank tumors. These data suggest that although replicating adenoviruses exhibit significant oncolytic activity, barriers within the established tumor, such as connective tissue and tumor matrix, may limit the spread of virus. Strategies to enhance viral spread through established tumors are therefore likely to greatly improve the therapeutic efficacy of replicating adenoviruses

Replicating adenoviral vectors are a promising new modality for cancer treatment and clinical trials with such vectors are ongoing. Targeting these vectors to cancer cells has been the focus of research. However, even if perfect targeting were to be achieved, a vector still must effectively kill cancer cells and spread throughout the bulk of the tumor. The adenoviral E1b-19kD protein is a potent inhibitor of apoptosis and may therefore compromise the therapeutic efficacy of an adenoviral vector. In this study we have investigated if an E1b-19kD gene deletion could improve the ability of a replicating adenoviral vector to spread through and kill cancer cells. In several lung cancer cell lines an E1b-19kD-deleted virus (Ad337) induced substantially more apoptosis than did a wild-type virus (Ad309), and tumor cell survival was significantly reduced in three of four cell lines. In addition, the apoptotic effects of cisplatin or paclitaxel were augmented by Ad337, but inhibited by wild-type virus. The number of infectious virus particles in the supernatant of infected cells was increased with Ad337 compared with wild-type virus, indicating enhanced early viral release. Ad337, in contrast to Ad309, induced significantly larger plaques after infection of A549 cells. This well-described large plaque phenotype of an E1b-19kD mutant virus is likely the result of early viral release and enhanced cell-to-cell viral spread. Loss of E1b-19kD function caused only minor cell line-specific increase or decrease in viral yield. We conclude that deletion of the E1b-19kD gene may enhance the tumoricidal effects of a replicating adenoviral vector

It has been proposed that an adenovirus with the E1b-55kD gene deleted has a selective advantage in replicating in cancer cells that have mutations in the p53 gene (Bischoff et al., 1996). We have explored this hypothesis in several lung cancer cell lines, and evaluated potential mechanisms that might regulate the replication of Ad338, an E1b-55kD-deleted virus, with the objective of developing a rational approach for targeting gene therapy to lung tumors. Our data show that Ad338 replicates poorly in three lung cancer cell lines with various p53 mutations (H441, H446, and Calu1), yet this virus replicates to a high level in a lung cancer cell line with wild-type p53 (A549) and in a normal lung fibroblast line (IMR90). Viral DNA replication, expression of viral proteins, and shutoff of host cell proteins were not important variables in limiting the replication of the E1b-55kD-deleted virus. However, the cell lines resistant to host cell protein shutoff were also the most resistant to the cytopathic effect induced by mutant and wild-type virus and the only cells to survive for 8 days following infection. The E1b-55kD protein clearly has an important role in viral replication beyond its interaction with p53. Thus, an E1b-55kD-deleted virus cannot be used to specifically target viral replication to p53-mutated lung cancer cells