Faculty Bibliography

BACKGROUND:It is a widely held view that congenital heart block (CHB) is caused by the transplacental transfer of maternal autoantibodies (anti-SSA/Ro and/or anti-SSB/La) into the fetal circulation. To test this hypothesis and to reproduce human CHB, an experimental mouse model (BALB/c) was developed by passive transfer of human autoantibodies into pregnant mice. METHODS AND RESULTS/RESULTS:Timed pregnant mice (n=54) were injected with a single intravenous bolus of purified IgG containing human anti-SSA/Ro and anti-SSB/La antibodies from mothers of children with CHB. To parallel the "window period" of susceptibility to CHB in humans, 3 groups of mice were used: 8, 11, and 16 days of gestation. Within each group, we tested 10, 25, 50, and 100 microg of IgG. At delivery, ECGs were recorded and analyzed for conduction abnormalities. Bradycardia and PR interval were significantly increased in 8-, 11-, and 16-day gestational groups when compared with controls (P<0.05). QRS duration was not significantly different between all groups. Antibody levels measured by ELISA in both mothers and their offspring confirmed the transplacental transfer of the human antibodies to the pups. CONCLUSIONS:The passive transfer model demonstrated bradycardia, first-degree but not complete atrioventricular block in pups. The greater percentage and degree of bradycardia and PR prolongation in the 11-day mouse group correlates with the "window period" of susceptibility observed in humans. The high incidence of bradycardia suggests possible sinoatrial node involvement. All together, these data provide relevant insights into the pathogenesis of CHB.

Irreversible congenital heart block (CHB) and the transient rash of neonatal lupus are strongly associated with maternal antibodies to SSA/Ro and SSB/La proteins; however, the precise mechanism by which these antibodies mediate organ-specific injury is not yet defined. Culturing of keratinocytes has provided critical insights. Accordingly, successful culturing of human fetal cardiac myocytes at high yield would constitute a powerful tool to directly examine conditions that promote expression of the target autoantigens. To accomplish this aim, fetal cardiac myocytes from 18- to 22-wk abortuses were established in culture using a novel technique in which cells were isolated after perfusion of the aorta with collagenase in a Langendorff apparatus. After preplating to decrease fibroblast contamination, cardiocytes were grown in flasks and slide chambers. Staining with monoclonal anti-sarcomeric alpha-actinin revealed the expected striations typical of cardiac myocytes in 70-90% of the cells after 4 d in culture. Furthermore, the cells were observed to beat at rates varying between 25-75 beats per minute (bpm) after the addition of 1.8 mM CaCl2. An average yield of 45-60 x 10(6) cells was obtained from a 3- to 5-g heart. Cellular localization of SSA/Ro and SSB/La by indirect immunofluorescence and demonstration of mRNA expression by reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction supports the feasibility of cultured cardiac myocytes for the study of congenital heart block. In contrast to the increased expression of SSA/Ro reported for keratinocytes, incubation of cultured human cardiac myocytes with either 17beta-estradiol or progesterone did not alter mRNA expression or cellular localization of 48 kD SSB/La, 52 kD SSA/Ro, or 60 kD SSA/Ro. In summary, we describe a novel method to successfully culture human fetal cardiac myocytes that should provide a valuable resource for investigation of the molecular mechanism(s) contributing to the development of congenital heart block. Differential constitutive and estradiol-induced expression of 52 and 60 kD SSA/Ro in human cardiac myocytes compared with keratinocytes may be a factor contributing to the marked discordance of clinically detectable injury in these two target tissues

In contrast to the objective of most clinical trials, which is to demonstrate superiority of an experimental treatment over a standard or placebo, the aim of an equivalence trial is to show that two treatments are equivalent in outcome or only marginally different. This would be of interest when an experimental treatment offers advantages such as reduced toxicity, ease of administration, or cost relative to the standard. Demonstrating equivalence may also be a goal when evaluating the safety of certain drugs because similarity in the risks of an adverse event in subjects exposed and unexposed to the drug is an indication of its safety. The classical formulation of the null hypothesis of treatment equality that is used in superiority trials is not applicable to equivalence trials because absolute equivalence between treatment groups cannot be proven. The strategy in equivalence trials is to define a maximum difference between treatment groups that is clinically acceptable and then assess whether there is sufficient evidence from the trial to conclude that the true treatment difference is within this acceptable range. In this paper, we discuss issues surrounding the planning, conduct, and analysis of equivalence trials in the context of SLE, with examples from the SELENA study

Multiple reliable and valid disease activities indices exist and have been used successfully in longitudinal studies. However, the definition of flare, using these intruments, has not been universally decided or accepted. Because flare is one of the three major patterns of lupus activity, it will remain an important outcome measure in both longitudinal and clinical trial studies

To correlate the arrhythmogenic effects of maternal autoantibodies with the genesis of congenital heart block, female BALB/c mice were immunized with human recombinant 48-kDa SSB/La, 60-kDa SSA/Ro, 52-kDa SSA/Ro (52alpha), and 52beta (amino acids 169-245 deleted) as well as with murine recombinant 52-kDa SSA/Ro. Control animals received beta-galactosidase or a polypeptide encoded by pET-28 alone. Following primary immunization and two boosters, high titer responses to the respective Ags were established by ELISA, immunoblotting, and immunoprecipitation. Sera from mice immunized with either human 52alpha or 52beta immunoprecipitated murine 52Ro. mRNA and protein expression of 52Ro was demonstrated in the newborn murine heart. A spectrum of atrioventricular nodal conduction abnormalities was identified by electrocardiogram. First-degree block was detected in 7% of 27 pups born to mothers immunized with 48La, 20% of 54 pups born to 60Ro-immunized mothers, 6% of 56 pups born to 52alpha-immunized mothers, 7% of 86 pups born to 52beta-immunized mothers, and 9% of 22 pups born to mothers immunized with murine 52Ro. Advanced conduction abnormalities were only identified in offspring of 52alpha- or 52beta-immunized mice. In the 52alpha group, one pup had complete block and another had second-degree block (Wenckebach type); in the 52beta group, five pups had complete block. Maternal Abs to the primary immunogens were detected in the pups. No control had any conduction abnormalities. This Ab-specific animal model provides strong evidence for a pathogenic role of anti-SSA/Ro-SSB/La Abs, particularly 52Ro, in the development of congenital heart block. The range and frequency of conduction defects suggest that additional factors promote disease expression

Access of intracellular Ags SSA/Ro and SSB/La to cognate maternal autoantibodies is unexplained despite their strong association with congenital heart block. To investigate the hypothesis that apoptosis facilitates surface accessibility of these Ags, human fetal cardiac myocytes from 16- to 22-wk abortuses were established in culture using a novel technique in which cells were isolated after perfusing the aorta with collagenase. Confirmation of cardiac myocytes included positive staining with antisarcomeric alpha-actinin and contractility induced by 1.8 mM calcium. Incubation with 0.5 microM staurosporine or 0.3 mM 2,3-dimethoxy-1,4-naphthoquinone induced the characteristic morphologic and biochemical changes of apoptosis. The cellular topology of Ro and La was evaluated with confocal microscopy and determined in nonapoptotic and apoptotic cardiocytes by indirect immunofluorescence. In permeabilized nonapoptotic cardiocytes, Ro and La were predominantly nuclear, and propidium iodide (PI) stained the nucleus. In early apoptotic cardiocytes, condensation of the PI- and Ro- or La-stained nucleus was observed, accompanied by Ro/La fluorescence around the cell periphery. In later stages of apoptosis, nuclear Ro and La staining became weaker, and PI demonstrated nuclear fragmentation. Ro/La-stained blebs emerged from the cell membrane, a finding observed in nonpermeabilized cells, supporting an Ab-Ag interaction at the cell surface. In summary, induction of apoptosis in cultured cardiocytes results in surface translocation of Ro/La and recognition by Abs. Although apoptotic cells are programmed to die and do not characteristically evoke inflammation, binding of maternal Abs and subsequent influx of leukocytes could damage surrounding healthy fetal cardiocytes