Perceptions of Critical Care Shortages, Resource Use, and Provider Well-being During the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Survey of 1,985 Health Care Providers in Brazil
Lobo, Suzana M; Creutzfeldt, Claire J; Maia, Israel S; Town, James A; Amorim, Edilberto; Kross, Erin K; Çoruh, Başak; Patel, Pratik V; Jannotta, Gemi E; Lewis, Ariane; Greer, David M; Curtis, J Randall; Sharma, Monisha; Wahlster, Sarah
BACKGROUND:Brazil has been disproportionately affected by COVID-19, placing a high burden on ICUs. RESEARCH QUESTION/OBJECTIVE:Are perceptions of ICU resource availability associated with end-of-life decisions and burnout among health-care providers (HCPs) during COVID-19 surges in Brazil? METHODS:We electronically administered a survey to multidisciplinary ICU HCPs during two 2-week periods (in June 2020 and March 2021) coinciding with COVID-19 surges. We examined responses across geographical regions and performed multivariate regressions to explore factors associated with reports of: (1) families being allowed less input in decisions about maintaining life-sustaining treatments for patients with COVID-19 and (2) emotional distress and burnout. RESULTS:We included 1,985 respondents (57% physicians, 14% nurses, 12% respiratory therapists, 16% other HCPs). More respondents reported shortages during the second surge compared with the first (P < .05 for all comparisons), including lower availability of intensivists (66% vs 42%), ICU nurses (53% vs 36%), ICU beds (68% vs 22%), and ventilators for patients with COVID-19 (80% vs 70%); shortages were highest in the North. One-quarter of HCPs reported that families were allowed less input in decisions about maintaining life-sustaining treatments for patients with COVID-19, which was associated with lack of intensivists (adjusted relative risk [aRR], 1.37; 95% CI, 1.05-1.80) and ICU beds (aRR, 1.71; 95% CI, 1.16-2.62) during the first surge and lack of N95 masks (aRR, 1.43; 95% CI, 1.10-1.85), noninvasive positive pressure ventilation (aRR, 1.56; 95% CI, 1.18-2.07), and oxygen concentrators (aRR, 1.50; 95% CI, 1.13-2.00) during the second surge. Burnout was higher during the second surge (60% vs 71%; P < .001), associated with witnessing colleagues at one's hospital contract COVID-19 during both surges (aRR, 1.55 [95% CI, 1.25-1.93] and 1.31 [95% CI, 1.11-1.55], respectively), as well as worries about finances (aRR, 1.28; 95% CI, 1.02-1.61) and lack of ICU nurses (aRR, 1.25; 95% CI, 1.02-1.53) during the first surge. CONCLUSIONS:During the COVID-19 pandemic, ICU HCPs in Brazil experienced substantial resource shortages, health-care disparities between regions, changes in end-of-life care associated with resource shortages, and high proportions of burnout.
PMCID:8828383
PMID: 35150658
ISSN: 1931-3543
CID: 5192392
Perceptions Regarding the SARS-CoV-2 Pandemic's Impact on Neurocritical Care Delivery: Results From a Global Survey
Lele, Abhijit V; Wahlster, Sarah; Alunpipachathai, Bhunyawee; Awraris Gebrewold, Meron; Chou, Sherry H-Y; Crabtree, Gretchen; English, Shane; Der-Nigoghossian, Caroline; Gagnon, David J; Kim-Tenser, May; Karanjia, Navaz; Kirkman, Matthew A; Lamperti, Massimo; Livesay, Sarah L; Mejia-Mantilla, Jorge; Melmed, Kara; Prabhakar, Hemanshu; Tumino, Leandro; Venkatasubba Rao, Chethan P; Udy, Andrew A; Videtta, Walter; Moheet, Asma M; Hinson, H E; Olm-Shipman, Casey M; Da Silva, Ivan; Cervantes-Arslanian, Anna M; Carlson, Andrew P; Sivakumar, Sanjeev; Shah, Vishank A; Bonomo, Jordan B; Hatton, Kevin W; Kapinos, Gregory; Hughes, Christopher G; RodrÃguez-Vega, Gloria M; Mainali, Shraddha; Chang, Cherylee W J; Dissin, Jonathan; Wang, Jing; Mailloux, Patrick T; Dhar, Rajat; Naik, Bhiken I; Sarwal, Aarti; Muehlschlegel, Susanne; Nobleza, Christa O'Hana S; Shapshak, Angela Hays; Wyler, David A; Latorre, Julius Gene S; Varelas, Panayiotis N; Ansari, Safdar A; Krishnamoorthy, Vijay; Rao, Shyam S; Ivan Da Silva, Demetrios J Kutsogiannis; Akbari, Yama; Rosenblatt, Kathryn; Roberts, Debra E; Kim, Jennifer A; Batra, Ayush; Srinivasan, Vasisht; Williamson, Craig A; Cai, Xuemei; George, Pravin; Pizzi, Michael A; Luk, K H Kevin; Berger, Karen; Babi, Marc-Alain; Hirsch, Karen G; Lay, Cappi C; Fontaine, Gabriel V; Lewis, Ariane; Lamer-Rosen, Amanda B; Kalanuria, Atul; Khawaja, Ayaz M; Rabinstein, Alejandro A; Andrews, Charles M; Badjatia, Neeraj; McDonagh, David L; Rajajee, Venkatakrishna; Dombrowski, Keith E; Daniels, Justin D; O'Phelan, Kristine H; Birrer, Kara L; Davis, Nicole C; Marino, Kaylee K; Li, Fanny; Sharma, Archit; Tesoro, Eljim P; Sadan, Ofer; Mehta, Yatin B; Boone, Myles Dustin; Barthol, Colleen; López Delgado, Hubiel J; Maricela, GarcÃa Arellano; Mijangos-Mendez, Julio C; Lopez-Pulgarin, Jose A; Terrett, Luke A; Rigamonti, Andrea; Couillard, Philippe; Chassé, Michaël; Al-Jehani, Hosam M; Cunto, Eleonora R; Villalobos, Luis M; Rocchetti, Nicolás S; Aparicio, Gabriela; Domeniconi, Gustavo G; Gemelli, Nicolas A; Badano, Mariana F; Costilla, Cesar M; Caporal, Paula; Camerlingo, Sebastián; Balasini, Carina; López, Rossana G; Mario, Mauri; Ilutovich, Santiago A; Torresan, Gabriela V; Mazzola, Ana M; Daniela, E; Olmos, K; Maldonado, Roberto Mérida; La Fuente Zerain, Gustavo; Paiva, Wellingson Silva; Falcão, Antônio Eiras; Rojas, Salomón; Franco, Gilberto Paulo Pereira; Azevedo, Renata A; Kurtz, Pedro; Balbo, Flor G; Carreno, Jose N; Rubiano, Andres M; Ciro, Juan Diego; Zulma Urbina, C; Pinto, Diego Barahona; Gómez, Pedro César Gutiérrez; Castillo, L; Ranero, Jorge Luis; Apodaca, Julio C; Gómez Arriola, Natalia E; Reátegui, RocÃo Nájar; Chumbe, Maria M; Rodriguez Tucto, Xandra Yanina; Davila Flores, Rafael E; Mora, Jacobo E; Al-Suwaidan, Faisal Abdulrahman; Abulhasan, Yasser B; Belay, Hanna Demissie; Kebede, Dawit K; Ewunetu, Mulugeta Biyadgie; Molla, Sisay; Tulu, Fitsum Alemu; Gebremariam, Senay A; Tibar, Houyam; Yimer, Fasika Tesfaneh; Farombi, Temitope Hannah; Xavier, Nshimiyimana Francios; Osman, Jama; Padayachy, Llewellyn C; Vander Laenen, Margot J; Breitenfeld, Tomislav; Takala, Riikka; Lasocki, Sigismond; Czorlich, Patrick; Poli, Sven; Neumann, Bernhard; Lochner, Piergiorgio; Menon, Sanjay; Wartenberg, Katja E; Wolf, Stefan; Etminan, Nima; Konczalla, Juergen; Schubert, Gerrit A; Wittstock, Matthias; Bösel, Julian; Robba, Chiara; De Cassai, Alessandro; Alampi, Daniela; Zugni, Nicola; Fuselli, Ennio; Bilotta, Federico; Stival, Eleonora; Castioni, Carlo Alberto; Tringali, Eleonora; Gelormini, Domenico; Dias, Celeste; Badenes, Rafael; Ramos-Gómez, Luis A; Llompart-Pou, Juan A; Tena, Susana Altaba; Merlani, Paolo; van den Bergh, Walter M; Hoedemaekers, Cornelia W; Abdo, Wilson F; van der Jagt, Mathieu; Gorbachov, Sergii; Dinsmore, J E; Reddy, Ugan; Tattum, L; Aneman, Anders; Rhodes, Jonathan K J; Sopheak, Pak; Jian, Song; Chan, Matthew Tv; Nagayama, Masao; Suzuki, Hidenori; Luthra, Ankur; Zirpe, Kapil G; Pratheema, R; Sethuraman, Manikandan; Tripathy, Swagata; Mahajan, Charu; Deb, Kallol; Gupta, Devendra; Gupta, Nidhi; Kapoor, Indu; Tandon, Monica S; Singhal, Vasudha; Parakh, Anil; Moningi, Srilata; Garg, Mudit; Sandhu, Kavita; Ali, Zulfiqar; Sharma, Vivek Bharti; Kumar, Subodh; Kumar, Prashant; Aggarwal, Deepesh G; Shukla, Urvi B; Dixit, Subhal; Nafissi, Shahriar; Mokhtari, Majid; Shrestha, Gentle S; Puvanendiran, Shanmugam; Sakchinabut, Sarunkorn; Kaewwinud, Jeerawat; Thirapattaraphan, Porntip; Petsakul, Suttasinee; Nuchpramool, Pruchwilai; Nitikaroon, Phongsak; Thaksin, Niyutta; Vongsfak, Jirapong; Sarapuddin, Gemmalynn B; Van Bui, Tuan; Seppelt, Oceania Ian M; Bhonagiri, Deepak; Winearls, James R; Flower, Oliver J; Westerlund, Torgeir A; Van Oosterwyck, Wout
BACKGROUND:The SARS-CoV-2 (COVID-19) pandemic has impacted many facets of critical care delivery. METHODS:An electronic survey was distributed to explore the pandemic's perceived impact on neurocritical care delivery between June 2020 and March 2021. Variables were stratified by World Bank country income level, presence of a dedicated neurocritical care unit (NCCU) and experiencing a COVID-19 patient surge. RESULTS:Respondents from 253 hospitals (78.3% response rate) from 47 countries (45.5% low/middle income countries; 54.5% with a dedicated NCCU; 78.6% experienced a first surge) participated in the study. Independent of country income level, NCCU and surge status, participants reported reductions in NCCU admissions (67%), critical care drug shortages (69%), reduction in ancillary services (43%) and routine diagnostic testing (61%), and temporary cancellation of didactic teaching (44%) and clinical/basic science research (70%). Respondents from low/middle income countries were more likely to report lack of surge preparedness (odds ratio [OR], 3.2; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.8-5.8) and struggling to return to prepandemic standards of care (OR, 12.2; 95% CI, 4.4-34) compared with respondents from high-income countries. Respondents experiencing a surge were more likely to report conversion of NCCUs and general-mixed intensive care units (ICUs) to a COVID-ICU (OR 3.7; 95% CI, 1.9-7.3), conversion of non-ICU beds to ICU\ beds (OR, 3.4; 95% CI, 1.8-6.5), and deviations in critical care and pharmaceutical practices (OR, 4.2; 95% CI 2.1-8.2). Respondents from hospitals with a dedicated NCCU were less likely to report conversion to a COVID-ICU (OR, 0.5; 95% CI, 0.3-0.9) or conversion of non-ICU to ICU beds (OR, 0.5; 95% CI, 0.3-0.9). CONCLUSION/CONCLUSIONS:This study reports the perceived impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on global neurocritical care delivery, and highlights shortcomings of health care infrastructures and the importance of pandemic preparedness.
PMID: 34882104
ISSN: 1537-1921
CID: 5326642