Faculty Bibliography

Clinicaltrials.gov, NCT02459327, NCT03945552 https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT02459327 . https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT03945552.

BACKGROUND:Efficacy of health-care based Early Relational Health (ERH) parenting interventions like PlayReadVIP and Smart Beginnings, are well-established, but limited research has examined parental perceptions of impact. OBJECTIVE:To explore parents' perceptions of how PlayReadVIP and SB support their parenting, generally and during the COVID-19 pandemic. METHODS:Nested sample of low-income parents enrolled in a two-site RCT of Smart Beginnings (SB), in New York City, NY (n = 40, 93% Latino) and Pittsburgh, PA (n = 40, 80% Black) and a single-site RCT of PlayReadVIP, Supporting Parents And Raising Resilient Kids (SPARRK), in Flint, MI (n = 40, 45% Black, 38% White). Interviews were audio taped and transcribed. Transcripts were coded using an iterative process of textual analysis until thematic saturation was reached. RESULTS:Four themes emerged: (1) Caregivers valued learning new, foundational parenting practices; (2) became more child-centered; (3) felt increased self-efficacy and empowerment; and (4) identified PlayReadVIP and SB as sources of support. CONCLUSIONS:Parents valued the ERH-aligned skills and concepts they learned in PlayReadVIP and SB and viewed the programs as sources of social support. Findings can inform and strengthen pediatric primary care-based parenting programs and have implications for feasibility, acceptability, and scaling of evidence-based and layered ERH programs. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION/BACKGROUND:Clinicaltrials.gov, NCT02459327, NCT03945552 https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT02459327 , https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT03945552 . IMPACT/CONCLUSIONS:Qualitative study demonstrating that parents value and learn Early Relational Health (ERH) skills from health-care based preventive parenting interventions. Findings inform adaptation, engagement, and scaling. Efficacy of parenting interventions (PlayReadVIP, Smart Beginnings) are well-established, but limited research has examined parental perceptions of impact. This study explores parents' experience with these programs to better understand core components and identify areas for adaptation and refinement. This study builds on prior quantitative work to demonstrate parents' perceived impact of and value in PlayReadVIP and Smart Beginnings. Parents reported participation in these programs/models resulted in enhancements to ERH, mind-mindedness, social support, and mental health.

OBJECTIVES/OBJECTIVE:Much research has documented disruptions to parent well-being and family functioning because of the COVID-19 pandemic in the United States, but little is known about how parents' provision of cognitive stimulation to young children has been affected. This question is of added importance for families with low incomes, who were disproportionately disadvantaged by the pandemic. The current study examined whether and how provision of cognitive stimulation at home, as measured by the parent-reported StimQ2, changed for parents with low incomes after onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. We examined scores on a total scale and subscales tapping multiple aspects of verbal responsivity and reading. DESIGN/METHODS:Data from 7 cohorts of families with low incomes across 3 US cities were de-identified and combined into a single analytic sample for secondary analysis. Cohorts ranged in timing relative to the onset of the pandemic (i.e., as early as 2015 and as late as April 2023). Each study contributed data from families assessed at multiple timepoints between birth and age 4 years. RESULTS:Total scores on the StimQ2 increased after the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic. Subscales reflecting reading stayed the same (quantity) or declined (quality), whereas subscales reflecting verbal responsivity increased. CONCLUSION/CONCLUSIONS:Relative to prepandemic levels, low-income parents' child-directed speech and responsivity increased postpandemic, but the quantity of parent-child reading was unchanged and its quality declined. Findings suggest the possibility of stability or improvement among parents with low incomes during the pandemic and opportunities for intervention.

OBJECTIVES/OBJECTIVE:To examine the effects of PlayReadVIP, a pediatric primary care intervention promoting early relational health, on child behaviors. STUDY DESIGN/METHODS:A factorial randomized controlled trial enrolled mother-child dyads postpartum. PlayReadVIP was delivered in two phases: birth to 3 years (PlayReadVIP 0-3) and 3 to 5 years (PlayReadVIP 3-5). At enrollment, dyads were assigned to PlayReadVIP 0-3 or control. At age 3, dyads were re-randomized to PlayReadVIP 3-5 or control. Analyses included dyads with a second randomization and complete data on the mediators and child outcomes. In PlayReadVIP, dyads attended one-on-one sessions with a parent coach, in which they received child development information, learning materials, and real-time, strengths-based feedback on brief video recordings of parent-child interactions. Cognitive stimulation and harsh discipline were reported by mothers. Child behaviors were assessed using the Behavior Assessment System for Children, Second Edition. RESULTS:grade. No significant indirect effects through harsh discipline were found. CONCLUSIONS:PlayReadVIP leads to sustained but small improvements in child behaviors by enhancing maternal cognitive stimulation, emphasizing the potential of early intervention in pediatric primary care for promoting child mental health in disadvantaged populations.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES/OBJECTIVE:Despite longstanding efforts to design, implement, and study parenting interventions early in life to address disparities in school readiness, gaps remain related to understanding their long-term effects and pathways of influence on child development. Here we describe sustained impacts at child age 6 of the innovative, tiered birth to age 3 Smart Beginnings (SB) model. METHODS:We performed a single-blind, 2-site randomized clinical trial of the SB model. SB integrates PlayReadVIP, a universal, pediatric primary care-based program, and Family Check-Up, a targeted secondary home-based parenting intervention. Mother-infant dyads (N = 403) were randomized at birth to standard pediatric care or the SB model. In line with SB's theory of change that supporting parents will promote their children's development, single and serial mediation pathways evaluated intervention effects of SB on age 6 child academic skills through parental cognitive stimulation at age 2 and child academic functioning at age 4. RESULTS:We found significant single and serially mediated indirect effects of SB on academic outcomes through parental cognitive stimulation in toddlerhood and preacademic skills in preschool. The total indirect pathways were positive and statistically significant for all academic outcomes at age 6, including receptive vocabulary (effect size [ES] = 0.04, P = .04), oral comprehension (ES = 0.05, P = .04), letter-word recognition (ES = 0.04, P = .04), phonemic decoding (ES = 0.04, P = .04), and applied problems (ES = 0.05, P = .04). CONCLUSIONS:Findings build on the demonstrated scalability of the SB model, support the cumulative process of academic functioning in childhood, and offer a promising model to address disparities early in life.

Children living in the rural US are more likely to live below the poverty line than their urban counterparts, and rural poverty is associated with greater disparities than urban poverty for many indicators of health, behavior, and school readiness. However, rural communities have often been overlooked in research focused on prevention of disparities in child development. Early Relational Health (ERH), which includes positive parenting practices and parent-child relationship quality, can support family resilience and buffer the consequences of racism, poverty, and related stressors on child development in families across geographical regions. In this narrative review, we describe the unique contextual factors within rural communities that facilitate and impose barriers to ERH and demonstrate the need for implementation and study of interventions that can support ERH in rural families. We describe platforms that have previously been used to deliver interventions in rural settings and recognize pediatric primary care as an underutilized context for supporting ERH and reducing disparities in child development in rural populations. Finally, we provide examples of key strategies that can reduce barriers to population-level delivery of interventions to rural families including improving access and providing culturally appropriate programming. Additional research is needed to address core gaps in the knowledge base related to prevention of inequities in rural populations through supporting ERH.

UNLABELLED:Social-emotional competence is critical to children's social and school success, prompting interest in understanding factors that promote these skills prior to elementary-school. Cognitive stimulation (e.g., reading, playing) is related to preschool children's social outcomes; However, few studies have examined these associations earlier, or determined whether interventions that encourage cognitive stimulation may enhance children's early social-emotional competencies either directly, or through impact on these behaviors. The present study examined whether cognitive stimulation in infancy predicted social competence in toddlerhood and the impact of a positive parenting intervention on these child outcomes. Mother-infant dyads in the Smart Beginnings (SB) RCT (primarily Hispanic/Latino or Black and from low-income backgrounds) were randomly assigned to treatment or control. SB integrates universal primary prevention in pediatric primary care (PlayReadVIP); and targeted/secondary prevention through home visiting (Family Check-Up). Mothers' cognitive stimulation at 6 months significantly predicted children's social-emotional competence at 24 months. Although there was no direct effect of SB on children's social-emotional competence, there was an indirect effect on children's social competence through maternal cognitive stimulation. Findings suggest that associations between cognitive stimulation and children's social-emotional competence emerge earlier than previously shown, and that positive parenting interventions can support early social-emotional competence through impact on cognitive stimulation. TRIAL REGISTRATION/UNASSIGNED:ClinicalTrials.gov identifier: NCT02459327.

The goal of this study was to examine the impacts of the Smart Beginnings (SB) intervention, a tiered model that combines universal primary prevention and targeted secondary prevention, on parental negative affect during discipline and children's externalizing behavior. Analyses included 273 families who were randomly assigned to SB or control groups at birth. Parental negative affect during discipline and child externalizing behavior were assessed through parent report at age four and six, respectively. Compared to the control group, families in SB had significantly reduced parental negative affect during discipline, with indirect effects on children's externalizing behavior through impacts on parent affect during discipline, both for the full sample and specifically for families with increased risks. Findings suggest that interventions aimed at promoting positive parent-child interactions may have important impacts on parenting behaviors and may prevent the onset of child behavior problems, with important implications for the implementation of preventive interventions. This study examined the impacts of the Smart Beginnings (SB) tiered model, which combines universal primary prevention and targeted secondary prevention, on parental negative demeanor during discipline-negative parental behavioral traits that are expressed through anger, verbal aggression, or demeaning behavior-and children's externalizing behavior. Analyses included 273 families randomly assigned to SB or control groups at birth. Parental negative demeanor during discipline was assessed through parent report (Socolar Discipline Survey) at age four and child externalizing behavior (CBCL) at age six. Compared to controls, regression analyses indicated that families in SB had significantly reduced parental negative demeanor during discipline, with mediation analyses suggesting indirect effects on child externalizing through impacts on parent demeanor during discipline, moderated by family risk level. Findings indicate that interventions aimed at promoting positive parent-child interactions may impact parenting behaviors and prevent onset of child behavior problems, with important implications for implementation of preventive interventions.

Parenting practices, such as reading aloud, teaching, and playing, make an important contribution to early relational health and are associated with long-term child development and school readiness. This study investigated whether participation in an evidence-based parent-child interaction programme (PlayReadVIP) adapted to Brazil for virtual delivery was associated with changes in cognitive stimulation. Employing a single-group pre- and post-intervention design, the study enrolled 15 mother-child dyads with children aged 5-56 months. Parents were interviewed before and after attending three sessions of PlayReadVIP to assess cognitive stimulation at home. Non-parametric within-group analyses indicated increased overall cognitive stimulation at home (Z = 3.10, p < .05), particularly in the context of reading activities (Z = 2.40, p < .05), parental involvement in children's development (Z = 2.62, p < .05), and parental responsivity (Z = 3.14, p < .05) after participation in three PlayReadVIP sessions. Findings suggest that the virtual, Brazilian adaptation of PlayReadVIP may benefit Brazilian families, even with a limited number of sessions.