Prognostic indicators and outcomes of hospitalised COVID-19 patients with neurological disease: An individual patient data meta-analysis
Singh, Bhagteshwar; Lant, Suzannah; Cividini, Sofia; Cattrall, Jonathan W S; Goodwin, Lynsey C; Benjamin, Laura; Michael, Benedict D; Khawaja, Ayaz; Matos, Aline de Moura Brasil; Alkeridy, Walid; Pilotto, Andrea; Lahiri, Durjoy; Rawlinson, Rebecca; Mhlanga, Sithembinkosi; Lopez, Evelyn C; Sargent, Brendan F; Somasundaran, Anushri; Tamborska, Arina; Webb, Glynn; Younas, Komal; Al Sami, Yaqub; Babu, Heavenna; Banks, Tristan; Cavallieri, Francesco; Cohen, Matthew; Davies, Emma; Dhar, Shalley; Fajardo Modol, Anna; Farooq, Hamzah; Harte, Jeffrey; Hey, Samuel; Joseph, Albert; Karthikappallil, Dileep; Kassahun, Daniel; Lipunga, Gareth; Mason, Rachel; Minton, Thomas; Mond, Gabrielle; Poxon, Joseph; Rabas, Sophie; Soothill, Germander; Zedde, Marialuisa; Yenkoyan, Konstantin; Brew, Bruce; Contini, Erika; Cysique, Lucette; Zhang, Xin; Maggi, Pietro; van Pesch, Vincent; Lechien, Jérome; Saussez, Sven; Heyse, Alex; Brito Ferreira, Maria Lúcia; Soares, Cristiane N; Elicer, Isabel; EugenÃn-von Bernhardi, Laura; Ñancupil Reyes, Waleng; Yin, Rong; Azab, Mohammed A; Abd-Allah, Foad; Elkady, Ahmed; Escalard, Simon; Corvol, Jean-Christophe; Delorme, Cécile; Tattevin, Pierre; Bigaut, Kévin; Lorenz, Norbert; Hornuss, Daniel; Hosp, Jonas; Rieg, Siegbert; Wagner, Dirk; Knier, Benjamin; Lingor, Paul; Winkler, Andrea Sylvia; Sharifi-Razavi, Athena; Moein, Shima T; SeyedAlinaghi, SeyedAhmad; JamaliMoghadamSiahkali, Saeidreza; Morassi, Mauro; Padovani, Alessandro; Giunta, Marcello; Libri, Ilenia; Beretta, Simone; Ravaglia, Sabrina; Foschi, Matteo; Calabresi, Paolo; Primiano, Guido; Servidei, Serenella; Biagio Mercuri, Nicola; Liguori, Claudio; Pierantozzi, Mariangela; Sarmati, Loredana; Boso, Federica; Garazzino, Silvia; Mariotto, Sara; Patrick, Kimani N; Costache, Oana; Pincherle, Alexander; Klok, Frederikus A; Meza, Roger; Cabreira, Verónica; Valdoleiros, Sofia R; Oliveira, Vanessa; Kaimovsky, Igor; Guekht, Alla; Koh, Jasmine; Fernández DÃaz, Eva; Barrios-López, José María; Guijarro-Castro, Cristina; Beltrán-Corbellini, Ãlvaro; Martínez-Poles, Javier; Diezma-MartÃn, Alba María; Morales-Casado, Maria Isabel; García García, Sergio; Breville, Gautier; Coen, Matteo; Uginet, Marjolaine; Bernard-Valnet, Raphaël; Du Pasquier, Renaud; Kaya, Yildiz; Abdelnour, Loay H; Rice, Claire; Morrison, Hamish; Defres, Sylviane; Huda, Saif; Enright, Noelle; Hassell, Jane; D'Anna, Lucio; Benger, Matthew; Sztriha, Laszlo; Raith, Eamon; Chinthapalli, Krishna; Nortley, Ross; Paterson, Ross; Chandratheva, Arvind; Werring, David J; Dervisevic, Samir; Harkness, Kirsty; Pinto, Ashwin; Jillella, Dinesh; Beach, Scott; Gunasekaran, Kulothungan; Rocha Ferreira Da Silva, Ivan; Nalleballe, Krishna; Santoro, Jonathan; Scullen, Tyler; Kahn, Lora; Kim, Carla Y; Thakur, Kiran T; Jain, Rajan; Umapathi, Thirugnanam; Nicholson, Timothy R; Sejvar, James J; Hodel, Eva Maria; Tudur Smith, Catrin; Solomon, Tom
BACKGROUND:Neurological COVID-19 disease has been reported widely, but published studies often lack information on neurological outcomes and prognostic risk factors. We aimed to describe the spectrum of neurological disease in hospitalised COVID-19 patients; characterise clinical outcomes; and investigate factors associated with a poor outcome. METHODS:We conducted an individual patient data (IPD) meta-analysis of hospitalised patients with neurological COVID-19 disease, using standard case definitions. We invited authors of studies from the first pandemic wave, plus clinicians in the Global COVID-Neuro Network with unpublished data, to contribute. We analysed features associated with poor outcome (moderate to severe disability or death, 3 to 6 on the modified Rankin Scale) using multivariable models. RESULTS:We included 83 studies (31 unpublished) providing IPD for 1979 patients with COVID-19 and acute new-onset neurological disease. Encephalopathy (978 [49%] patients) and cerebrovascular events (506 [26%]) were the most common diagnoses. Respiratory and systemic symptoms preceded neurological features in 93% of patients; one third developed neurological disease after hospital admission. A poor outcome was more common in patients with cerebrovascular events (76% [95% CI 67-82]), than encephalopathy (54% [42-65]). Intensive care use was high (38% [35-41]) overall, and also greater in the cerebrovascular patients. In the cerebrovascular, but not encephalopathic patients, risk factors for poor outcome included breathlessness on admission and elevated D-dimer. Overall, 30-day mortality was 30% [27-32]. The hazard of death was comparatively lower for patients in the WHO European region. INTERPRETATION:Neurological COVID-19 disease poses a considerable burden in terms of disease outcomes and use of hospital resources from prolonged intensive care and inpatient admission; preliminary data suggest these may differ according to WHO regions and country income levels. The different risk factors for encephalopathy and stroke suggest different disease mechanisms which may be amenable to intervention, especially in those who develop neurological symptoms after hospital admission.
PMCID:9162376
PMID: 35653330
ISSN: 1932-6203
CID: 5277632
Global Impact of COVID-19 on Stroke Care and Intravenous Thrombolysis
Nogueira, Raul G; Qureshi, Muhammed M; Abdalkader, Mohamad; Martins, Sheila Ouriques; Yamagami, Hiroshi; Qiu, Zhongming; Mansour, Ossama Yassin; Sathya, Anvitha; Czlonkowska, Anna; Tsivgoulis, Georgios; Aguiar de Sousa, Diana; Demeestere, Jelle; Mikulik, Robert; Vanacker, Peter; Siegler, James E; Kõrv, Janika; Biller, Jose; Liang, Conrad W; Sangha, Navdeep S; Zha, Alicia M; Czap, Alexandra L; Holmstedt, Christine Anne; Turan, Tanya N; Ntaios, George; Malhotra, Konark; Tayal, Ashis; Loochtan, Aaron; Ranta, Annamarei; Mistry, Eva A; Alexandrov, Anne W; Huang, David Y; Yaghi, Shadi; Raz, Eytan; Sheth, Sunil A; Mohammaden, Mahmoud H; Frankel, Michael; Bila Lamou, Eric Guemekane; Aref, Hany M; Elbassiouny, Ahmed; Hassan, Farouk; Menecie, Tarek; Mustafa, Wessam; Shokri, Hossam M; Roushdy, Tamer; Sarfo, Fred S; Alabi, Tolulope Oyetunde; Arabambi, Babawale; Nwazor, Ernest O; Sunmonu, Taofiki Ajao; Wahab, Kolawole; Yaria, Joseph; Mohammed, Haytham Hussein; Adebayo, Philip B; Riahi, Anis D; Ben Sassi, Samia; Gwaunza, Lenon; Ngwende, Gift Wilson; Sahakyan, David; Rahman, Aminur; Ai, Zhibing; Bai, Fanghui; Duan, Zhenhui; Hao, Yonggang; Huang, Wenguo; Li, Guangwen; Li, Wei; Liu, Ganzhe; Luo, Jun; Shang, Xianjin; Sui, Yi; Tian, Ling; Wen, Hongbin; Wu, Bo; Yan, Yuying; Yuan, Zhengzhou; Zhang, Hao; Zhang, Jun; Zhao, Wenlong; Zi, Wenjie; Leung, Thomas W; Chugh, Chandril; Huded, Vikram; Menon, Bindu; Pandian, Jeyaraj Durai; Sylaja, P N; Usman, Fritz Sumantri; Farhoudi, Mehdi; Hokmabadi, Elyar Sadeghi; Horev, Anat; Reznik, Anna; Hoffmann, Rotem Sivan; Ohara, Nobuyuki; Sakai, Nobuyuki; Watanabe, Daisuke; Yamamoto, Ryoo; Doijiri, Ryosuke; Tokuda, Naoki; Yamada, Takehiro; Terasaki, Tadashi; Yazawa, Yukako; Uwatoko, Takeshi; Dembo, Tomohisa; Shimizu, Hisao; Sugiura, Yuri; Miyashita, Fumio; Fukuda, Hiroki; Miyake, Kosuke; Shimbo, Junsuke; Sugimura, Yusuke; Yagita, Yoshiki; Takenobu, Yohei; Matsumaru, Yuji; Yamada, Satoshi; Kono, Ryuhei; Kanamaru, Takuya; Yamazaki, Hidekazu; Sakaguchi, Manabu; Todo, Kenichi; Yamamoto, Nobuaki; Sonoda, Kazutaka; Yoshida, Tomoko; Hashimoto, Hiroyuki; Nakahara, Ichiro; Kondybayeva, Aida; Faizullina, Kamila; Kamenova, Saltanat; Zhanuzakov, Murat; Baek, Jang-Hyun; Hwang, Yangha; Lee, Jin Soo; Lee, Si Baek; Moon, Jusun; Park, Hyungjong; Seo, Jung Hwa; Seo, Kwon-Duk; Sohn, Sung Il; Young, Chang Jun; Ahdab, Rechdi; Wan Zaidi, Wan Asyraf; Aziz, Zariah Abdul; Basri, Hamidon Bin; Chung, Law Wan; Ibrahim, Aznita Binti; Ibrahim, Khairul Azmi; Looi, Irene; Tan, Wee Yong; Yahya, Nafisah Wan; Groppa, Stanislav; Leahu, Pavel; Al Hashmi, Amal M; Imam, Yahia Zakaria; Akhtar, Naveed; Pineda-Franks, Maria Carissa; Co, Christian Oliver; Kandyba, Dmitriy; Alhazzani, Adel; Al-Jehani, Hosam; Tham, Carol Huilian; Mamauag, Marlie Jane; Venketasubramanian, Narayanaswamy; Chen, Chih-Hao; Tang, Sung-Chun; Churojana, Anchalee; Akil, Esref; Aykaç, Ozlem; Ozdemir, Atilla Ozcan; Giray, Semih; Hussain, Syed Irteza; John, Seby; Le Vu, Huynh; Tran, Anh Duc; Nguyen, Huy Hoang; Pham, Thong Nhu; Nguyen, Thang Huy; Nguyen, Trung Quoc; Gattringer, Thomas; Enzinger, Christian; Killer-Oberpfalzer, Monika; Bellante, Flavio; De Blauwe, Sofie; Vanhooren, Geert; De Raedt, Sylvie; Dusart, Anne; Lemmens, Robin; Ligot, Noemie; Rutgers, Matthieu Pierre; Yperzeele, Laetitia; Alexiev, Filip; Sakelarova, Teodora; Bedeković, Marina Roje; Budincevic, Hrvoje; Cindrić, Igor; Hucika, Zlatko; Ozretic, David; Saric, Majda Seferovic; Pfeifer, Frantiek; Karpowic, Igor; Cernik, David; Sramek, Martin; Skoda, Miroslav; Hlavacova, Helena; Klecka, Lukas; Koutny, Martin; Vaclavik, Daniel; Skoda, Ondrej; Fiksa, Jan; Hanelova, Katerina; Nevsimalova, Miroslava; Rezek, Robert; Prochazka, Petr; Krejstova, Gabriela; Neumann, Jiri; Vachova, Marta; Brzezanski, Henryk; Hlinovsky, David; Tenora, Dusan; Jura, Rene; Jurák, LubomÃr; Novak, Jan; Novak, Ales; Topinka, Zdenek; Fibrich, Petr; Sobolova, Helena; Volny, Ondrej; Christensen, Hanne Krarup; Drenck, Nicolas; Iversen, Helle Klingenberg; Simonsen, Claus Z; Truelsen, Thomas Clement; Wienecke, Troels; Vibo, Riina; Gross-Paju, Katrin; Toomsoo, Toomas; Antsov, Katrin; Caparros, Francois; Cordonnier, Charlotte; Dan, Maria; Faucheux, Jean-Marc; Mechtouff, Laura; Eker, Omer; Lesaine, Emilie; Ondze, Basile; Peres, Roxane; Pico, Fernando; Piotin, Michel; Pop, Raoul; Rouanet, Francois; Gubeladze, Tatuli; Khinikadze, Mirza; Lobjanidze, Nino; Tsikaridze, Alexander; Nagel, Simon; Ringleb, Peter Arthur; Rosenkranz, Michael; Schmidt, Holger; Sedghi, Annahita; Siepmann, Timo; Szabo, Kristina; Thomalla, Götz; Palaiodimou, Lina; Sagris, Dimitrios; Kargiotis, Odysseas; Klivenyi, Peter; Szapary, Laszlo; Tarkanyi, Gabor; Adami, Alessandro; Bandini, Fabio; Calabresi, Paolo; Frisullo, Giovanni; Renieri, Leonardo; Sangalli, Davide; Pirson, Anne V; Uyttenboogaart, Maarten; van den Wijngaard, Ido; Kristoffersen, Espen Saxhaug; Brola, Waldemar; Fudala, MaÅ‚gorzata; Horoch-Lyszczarek, Ewa; Karlinski, Michal; Kazmierski, Radoslaw; Kram, Pawel; Rogoziewicz, Marcin; Kaczorowski, Rafal; Luchowski, Piotr; Sienkiewicz-Jarosz, Halina; Sobolewski, Piotr; Fryze, Waldemar; Wisniewska, Anna; Wiszniewska, Malgorzata; Ferreira, Patricia; Ferreira, Paulo; Fonseca, Luisa; Marto, João Pedro; Pinho E Melo, Teresa; Nunes, Ana Paiva; Rodrigues, Miguel; Cruz, VÃtor Tedim; Falup-Pecurariu, Cristian; Krastev, Georgi; Mako, Miroslav; Alonso de Leciñana, María; Arenillas, Juan F; Ayo-Martin, Oscar; Culebras, Antonio Cruz; Tejedor, Exuperio Diez; Montaner, Joan; Pérez-Sánchez, Soledad; Tola Arribas, Miguel Angel; Vasquez, Alejandro Rodriguez; Mazya, Michael; Bernava, Gianmarco; Brehm, Alex; Machi, Paolo; Fischer, Urs; Gralla, Jan; Michel, Patrik L; Psychogios, Marios-Nikos; Strambo, Davide; Banerjee, Soma; Krishnan, Kailash; Kwan, Joseph; Butt, Asif; Catanese, Luciana; Demchuk, Andrew; Field, Thalia; Haynes, Jennifer; Hill, Michael D; Khosravani, Houman; Mackey, Ariane; Pikula, Aleksandra; Saposnik, Gustavo; Scott, Courtney Anne; Shoamanesh, Ashkan; Shuaib, Ashfaq; Yip, Samuel; Barboza, Miguel A; Barrientos, Jose Domingo; Portillo Rivera, Ligia Ibeth; Gongora-Rivera, Fernando; Novarro-Escudero, Nelson; Blanco, Anmylene; Abraham, Michael; Alsbrook, Diana; Altschul, Dorothea; Alvarado-Ortiz, Anthony J; Bach, Ivo; Badruddin, Aamir; Barazangi, Nobl; Brereton, Charmaine; Castonguay, Alicia; Chaturvedi, Seemant; Chaudhry, Saqib A; Choe, Hana; Choi, Jae H; Dharmadhikari, Sushrut; Desai, Kinjal; Devlin, Thomas G; Doss, Vinodh T; Edgell, Randall; Etherton, Mark; Farooqui, Mudassir; Frei, Don; Gandhi, Dheeraj; Grigoryan, Mikayel; Gupta, Rishi; Hassan, Ameer E; Helenius, Johanna; Kaliaev, Artem; Kaushal, Ritesh; Khandelwal, Priyank; Khawaja, Ayaz M; Khoury, Naim N; Kim, Benny S; Kleindorfer, Dawn O; Koyfman, Feliks; Lee, Vivien H; Leung, Lester Y; Linares, Guillermo; Linfante, Italo; Lutsep, Helmi L; Macdougall, Lisa; Male, Shailesh; Malik, Amer; Masoud, Hesham; McDermott, Molly; Mehta, Brijesh P; Min, Jiangyong; Mittal, Manoj; Morris, Jane G; Multani, Sumeet S; Nahab, Fadi; Nalleballe, Krishna; Nguyen, Claude B; Novakovic-White, Roberta; Ortega-Gutierrez, Santiago; Rahangdale, Rahul H; Ramakrishnan, Pankajavalli; Romero, Jose Rafael; Rost, Natalia; Rothstein, Aaron; Ruland, Sean; Shah, Ruchir; Sharma, Malveeka; Silver, Brian; Simmons, Marc; Singh, Abhishek; Starosciak, Amy K; Strasser, Sheryl L; Szeder, Viktor; Teleb, Mohamed; Tsai, Jenny P; Voetsch, Barbara; Balaguera, Oscar; Pujol Lereis, Virginia A; Luraschi, Adriana; Almeida, Marcele Schettini; Cardoso, Fabricio Buchdid; Conforto, Adriana; De Deus Silva, Leonardo; Giacomini, Luidia Varrone; Lima, Fabricio Oliveira; Longo, Alexandre L; Magalhães, Pedro Sc; Martins, Rodrigo Targa; Mont'alverne, Francisco; Mora Cuervo, Daissy Liliana; Rebello, Leticia Costa; Valler, Lenise; Zetola, Viviane Flumignan; Lavados, Pablo M; Navia, Victor; OlavarrÃa, Verónica V; Almeida Toro, Juan Manuel; Ricardo Amaya, Pablo Felipe; Bayona, Hernan; Corredor-Quintero, Angel Basilio; Rivera Ordonez, Carlos Eduardo; Mantilla Barbosa, Diana Katherine; Lara, Osvaldo; Patiño, Mauricio R; Diaz Escobar, Luis Fernando; Dejesus Melgarejo Farina, Donoband Edson; Villamayor, Analia Cardozo; Zelaya Zarza, Adolfo Javier; Barrientos Iman, Danny Moises; Kadota, Liliana Rodriguez; Campbell, Bruce; Hankey, Graeme J; Hair, Casey; Kleinig, Timothy; Ma, Alice; Martins, Rodrigo Tomazini; Sahathevan, Ramesh; Thijs, Vincent; Salazar, Daniel; Yuan-Hao Wu, Teddy; Haussen, Diogo C; Liebeskind, David; Yavagal, Dileep; Jovin, Tudor G; Zaidat, Osama O; Nguyen, Thanh N
OBJECTIVE:The objectives of this study were to measure the global impact of the pandemic on the volumes for intravenous thrombolysis (IVT), IVT transfers, and stroke hospitalizations over 4 months at the height of the pandemic (March 1 to June 30, 2020) compared with two control 4-month periods. METHODS:We conducted a cross-sectional, observational, retrospective study across 6 continents, 70 countries, and 457 stroke centers. Diagnoses were identified by their ICD-10 codes and/or classifications in stroke databases. RESULTS:There were 91,373 stroke admissions in the 4 months immediately before compared to 80,894 admissions during the pandemic months, representing an 11.5% (95%CI, -11.7 to - 11.3, p<0.0001) decline. There were 13,334 IVT therapies in the 4 months preceding compared to 11,570 procedures during the pandemic, representing a 13.2% (95%CI, -13.8 to -12.7, p<0.0001) drop. Interfacility IVT transfers decreased from 1,337 to 1,178, or an 11.9% decrease (95%CI, -13.7 to -10.3, p=0.001). Recovery of stroke hospitalization volume (9.5%, 95%CI 9.2-9.8, p<0.0001) was noted over the two later (May, June) versus the two earlier (March, April) pandemic months. There was a 1.48% stroke rate across 119,967 COVID-19 hospitalizations. SARS-CoV-2 infection was noted in 3.3% (1,722/52,026) of all stroke admissions. CONCLUSIONS:The COVID-19 pandemic was associated with a global decline in the volume of stroke hospitalizations, IVT, and interfacility IVT transfers. Primary stroke centers and centers with higher COVID19 inpatient volumes experienced steeper declines. Recovery of stroke hospitalization was noted in the later pandemic months.
PMID: 33766997
ISSN: 1526-632x
CID: 4822932