Training Latin American primary care physicians in the WPA module on depression: results of a multicenter trial
Levav, Itzhak; Kohn, Robert; Montoya, Ivan; Palacio, Carlos; Rozic, Pablo; Solano, Ida; Valentini, Willians; Vicente, Benjamin; Morales, Jorge Castro; Eigueta, Francisco Espejo; Saravanan, Yamini; Miranda, Claudio T; Sartorius, Norman
BACKGROUND: In order to improve care for people with depressive disorders and to reduce the increasing burden of depression, the American Regional Office of the World Health Organization has launched a major region-wide initiative. A central part of this effort was directed to the primary care system where the diagnosis and treatment of depression are deficient in many countries. This study evaluated the materials developed by the World Psychiatric Association in a training program on depression among primary care physicians by measuring changes in their knowledge, attitudes, and practice (KAP). METHOD: One hundred and seven physicians and 6174 patients from five Latin American countries participated in the trial. KAP were assessed 1 month before and 1 month following the training program. In addition, the presence of depressive symptoms was measured in patients who visited the clinic during a typical week at both times using the Zung Depression Scale and a DSM-IV/ ICD-10 major depression checklist. RESULTS: The program slightly improved knowledge about depression and modified some attitudes, but had limited impact on actual practice. There was no evidence that the diagnosis of depression was made more frequently, nor was there an improvement in psychopharmacological management. The post-training agreement between physician diagnosis and that based on patient self-report remained low. The physicians, however, seemed more confident in treating depressed patients after training, and referred fewer patients to psychiatrists. CONCLUSIONS: Traditional means of training primary care physicians in depression have little impact on clinical practice regardless of the quality of the teaching materials
PMCID:2723767
PMID: 15842027
ISSN: 0033-2917
CID: 143482
Changing aspects of psychiatric inpatient treatment. A census investigation in five European countries
Rittmannsberger, Hans; Sartorius, Norman; Brad, Mihaela; Burtea, Victoria; Capraru, Nora; Cernak, Pavel; Dernovcek, Mojca; Dobrin, Ionescu; Frater, Rosa; Hasto, Jozef; Hategan, Mieta; Haushofer, Manfred; Kafka, J; Kasper, Siegfried; Macrea, Rodica; Nabelek, Ludvik; Nawka, Peter; Novotny, Vladimir; Platz, Thomas; Pojar, Adela; Silberbauer, Christoph; Fekete, Sandor; Wancata, Johannes; Windhager, Elmar; Zapotoczky, Hans-Georg; Zochling, Robert
This paper presents data obtained in a one-day census investigation in five European countries (Austria, Hungary, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia). The census forms were filled in for 4191 psychiatric inpatients. Concerning legal status, 11.2% were hospitalised against their will (committed) and 21.4% were treated in a ward with locked doors. There was only a small correlation between commitment and treatment in a locked ward. More frequent than treatment of committed patients in locked wards was treatment of committed patients in open wards (Austria, Hungary) and treatment of voluntary patients in closed wards (Slovakia, Slovenia). Concerning employment, 27.7% of patients aged 18-60 held a job before admission. The vast majority of patients (84.8%) had a length of stay of less than 3 months. A comparison of these data with the results of a study performed in 1996 and using the same method shows a decrease of rates of long-stay patients. In 1996 the rates of employment were significantly higher in Romania (39.3%) and Slovakia (42.5%) compared to Austria (30.7%). These differences disappeared in 1999 due to decreasing rates of employment in Romania and Slovakia. The numbers of mental health personnel varies between types of institution (university or non-university) and countries, being highest in Austria and lowest in Romania. A considerable increase in the numbers of staff was found in Slovakia
PMID: 15589707
ISSN: 0924-9338
CID: 143484
Attitudes of psychiatrists toward patients with schizophrenia
Ucok, Alp; Polat, Aslihan; Sartorius, Norman; Erkoc, Sahap; Atakli, Cem
A questionnaire was distributed to psychiatrists to investigate their attitudes toward patients with schizophrenia. A total of 42.7% of 60 respondents never informed patients of the diagnosis of schizophrenia and 40.7% informed on a case-by-case basis. The reason that psychiatrists gave for avoiding informing the patients/family members of the diagnosis was the idea that they would not understand the meaning (32.6%) and that they would drop-out from treatment (28.3%). A total of 88.4% of respondents thought the term 'schizophrenia' was used in a pejorative manner in public. The findings revealed that stigmatizing attitudes of society are also shared by some psychiatrists
PMID: 14678463
ISSN: 1323-1316
CID: 143490