Faculty Bibliography

This paper will explore emerging concepts related to alternative carcinogenic mechanisms of 'non-mutagenic,' and hence epigenetic, carcinogens that may heritably alter DNA methylation without changing the underlying DNA sequence. In this review, we will touch on the basic concepts of DNA methylation, and will elaborate in greater detail on related topics including chromatin condensation, and heterochromatin spreading that is well known to induce gene silencing by position effect variegation in Drosophila and other species. Data from our model transgenic G12 cell system will be presented to support our hypothesis that certain carcinogens, such as nickel, may be carcinogenic not primarily because of their overt mutability, but rather as the result of their ability to promote DNA hypermethylation of important cancer-related genes. We will conclude with a discussion of the broader relevance of our findings and its application to other so-called 'epigenetic' carcinogens

The transgenic cell lines G12 and G10, each with a bacterial gpt gene stably integrated at a single but different position in the Chinese hamster genome, were evaluated for deletion of the gpt transgene following exposures to several clastogens. More than 150 independently cloned G12 and G10 6-thioguanine-resistant mutants have been characterized by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) amplification and Southern blots in this study. Despite differences in the integration sites for the gpt gene in the G12 and G10 cells, PCR amplification of the gpt gene from both cell lines can be performed using the same single set of primers. By PCR deletion screening, about 20% of recovered spontaneous 6-thioguanine resistant (6TG) gpt G12 mutants had deleted the transgene, whereas the deletion mutant frequency was increased to about 50% of the X-ray- and bleomycin-induced G12 mutants. In contrast, both spontaneous and induced deletion frequencies are considerably higher for the G10 cell line. Among spontaneous G10 mutants, up to 50% have deleted the gpt transgene, whereas almost all of the X-ray- and bleomycin-induced G10 mutants have lost the integrated gene sequence. These results are discussed in the context of the transgene integration sites and the influences of the surrounding genome that may render certain genetic regions prone to deletion

Oxidative stress has been implicated in carcinogenesis yet there are chemicals that produce oxidative stress that are not carcinogenic. Mutations are the inherited results of DNA damage and are critical events in carcinogenesis. The mutagenicity of oxidative stress induced by peroxide, paraquat and cobalt compounds was examined in transgenic gpt+ Chinese hamster cell lines (G12 and G10). These two cell lines are known to be more sensitive to mutagens such as X-rays and UV than their parental V-79 cells. In these studies, the mutagenic activity of cobalt chloride, a metal that induces oxidative stress but is not carcinogenic, was measured to be 7.7 times higher than the spontaneous mutant frequency in G12, but was only 1.5 to 2.5 times higher than spontaneous mutant frequency in G10 cells. The mutant frequency of cobalt sulfide was somewhat lower. Hydrogen peroxide was found to be only weakly mutagenic in G12 cells, and treatment of cells with a combination of hydrogen peroxide and cobalt did not alter the mutation frequency induced by cobalt sulfide alone. Paraquat did not elicit mutagenesis in either cell line. These results indicate that agents producing oxidative stress are not necessarily mutagenic and these results are discussed in the context of the oxidative stress produced by other carcinogens such as nickel compounds

A transgenic gpt+ Chinese hamster cell line (G12) was found to be susceptible to carcinogenic nickel-induced inactivation of gpt expression without mutagenesis or deletion of the transgene. Many nickel-induced 6-thioguanine-resistant variants spontaneously reverted to actively express gpt, as indicated by both reversion assays and direct enzyme measurements. Since reversion was enhanced in many of the nickel-induced variant cell lines following 24-h treatment with the demethylating agent 5-azacytidine, the involvement of DNA methylation in silencing gpt expression was suspected. This was confirmed by demonstrations of increased DNA methylation, as well as by evidence indicating condensed chromatin and heterochromatinization of the gpt integration site in 6-thioguanine-resistant cells. Upon reversion to active gpt expression, DNA methylation and condensation are lost. We propose that DNA condensation and methylation result in heterochromatinization of the gpt sequence with subsequent inheritance of the now silenced gene. This mechanism is supported by direct evidence showing that acute nickel treatment of cultured cells, and of isolated nuclei in vitro, can indeed facilitate gpt sequence-specific chromatin condensation. Epigenetic mechanisms have been implicated in the actions of some nonmutagenic carcinogens, and DNA methylation changes are now known to be important in carcinogenesis. This paper further supports the emerging theory that nickel is a human carcinogen that can alter gene expression by enhanced DNA methylation and compaction, rather than by mutagenic mechanisms

Carcinogenic, water-insoluble Ni compounds are phagocytized by cells; and the particles undergo dissolution inside the cell, releasing Ni ions that interact with chromatin. Ni produces highly selective damage to heterochromatin. The longest contiguous region of heterochromatin in the Chinese hamster genome is found on the q arm of the X chromosome, and this region is selectively damaged by Ni. More than half of the male mice in which there were Ni-induced transformations of Chinese hamster cells exhibited complete deletion of the long arm of the X chromosome. The introduction of a normal X chromosome into these cells resulted in cellular senescence, suggesting that the Ni interacted with Chinese hamster genome to inactivate a senescence gene. Investigations were conducted into the mechanisms by which Ni produced damage to chromatin. Ni ions have a much higher affinity for proteins and amino acids than for DNA (by five to seven orders of magnitude). Therefore, Ni interacted with chromatin because of the protein present, not because of its reactivity for DNA. Studies have shown that Ni produced an increase in oxidative products in cells as indicated by oxidation of the fluorescent dye dichlorofluorescein; Ni has also been shown to produce oxidation of proteins in cells, as measured by carbonyl formation. Ni cross-linked certain amino acids and proteins to DNA. These covalent cross-links were not dissociated by EDTA and are inconsistent with direct Ni involvement, but they are consistent with Ni acting catalytically. Using subtractive hybridization, we have isolated a number of clones that are expressed in normal but not in Ni-transformed cells.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Increasing evidence demonstrates the reactive oxygen species (ROS) are implicated in metal carcinogenesis. Exposure of cultured Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells to several nickel compounds, i.e. NiS, Ni3S2, NiO (black and green), and NiCl2 has been shown to increase oxidation of 2',7-dichlorofluorescein to the fluorescent 2',7-dichlorofluorescein (DCF), suggesting that nickel compounds increased the concentration of oxidants in CHO cells. This fluorescence can be attenuated by addition of exogenous catalase to the extracellular media, indicating that H2O2 is one of the formed oxidants in this system. Fluorimetric measurements of chromogens following thiobarbituric acid reaction showed that nickel compounds also induce lipid peroxidation with a decreasing potency NiS, Ni3S2 > black NiO > green NiO > NiCl2. These results suggest that lipid hydroperoxides may also be produced through the action of nickel in intact cells. MgCl2, an antagonist of Ni-induced DNA strand breaks and cell transformation, has no effect on the formation of DCF fluorescence induced in CHO cells by nickel. The results suggest that nickel is an active inducer of ROS in intact mammalian cells and that the molecular mechanism of nickel carcinogenesis may involve multiple steps of nickel-mediated ROS

Metals are toxic agents for which genotoxic effects are often difficult to demonstrate. To study metal mutagenesis, we have used two stable hprt/gpt+ transgenic cell lines that were derived from Chinese hamster V79 cells. Both the G12 and G10 cell lines are known to be very sensitive to clastogens such as X-rays and bleomycin, with the mutagenic response of the integrated xanthine guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (gpt) gene in G10 usually exceeding that of the same gene in the transgenic G12 cells. In studies with carcinogenic insoluble nickel compounds, a high level of mutagenesis was found at the gpt locus of G12 cells but not at the endogenous hypoxanthine phosphoribosyl transferase (hprt) locus of V79 cells. We have since demonstrated the similar recovery of a high frequency of viable G12 mutants with other insoluble nickel salts including nickel oxides (black and green). The relative mutant yield for the insoluble nickel compounds (G12 > G10) is the opposite of that obtained with nonmetal clastogens (G10 > G12). In the G12 cells, nickel mutagenesis may be related to the integration of the gpt sequence into a heterochromatic region of the genome. For some of the insoluble nickel compounds, significant inhibition of both cytotoxicity and mutant yield resulted when the G12 cells were pretreated with vitamin E. In comparison with the nickel studies, the mutagenic responses to chromium compounds in these cell lines were not as dramatic. Mutagenesis of the gpt target could not be demonstrated with other metals such as mercury or vanadium